| Year | Month | Day | Club 1 | C1 Location | C1 Runs | Club 2 | C2 Location | C2 Runs | Venue | Inn | Hrs | City | Borough | State | Source | Date | Other | |
| 1867 | Jan. | 5 | Camden | Camden | 19 | Athletic | Philadelphia | 27 | skating park | 5 | Camden | NJ | NYC | 12-Jan | ice | |||
| 1867 | Jan. | 16 | Eagle | New York | 13 | Empire | New York | 15 | Sylvan Lake | 5 | 1.75 | Hoboken | Hudson County | NJ | NYC | 26-Jan | ice | |
| 1867 | Feb. | 22 | Eagle | San Francisco | 70 | Pacific | San Francisco | 32 | 6 | 1.66 | Mobile | AL | NYC | 30-Mar | ||||
| 1867 | Feb. | 26 | Dramatic | Mobile | 28 | Star | Mobile | 24 | San Francisco | CA | NYC | 13-Apr | ||||||
| 1867 | Mar. | 2 | Lookout | Chattanooga | 49 | Lightfoot | Chattanooga | 19 | Chattanooga | TN | NYC | 23-Mar | ||||||
| 1867 | Mar. | 2 | Hornets Nest | Charlotte | 65 | Fair Grounds | Charlotte | 16 | Charlotte | NC | NYC | 30-Mar | ||||||
| 1867 | Mar. | 7 | National | Raleigh | 49 | Meteor | New Bern | 36 | 9 | Atlanta | GA | NYC | 6-Apr | |||||
| 1867 | Mar. | 14 | Gate City | Atlanta | 108 | Atlanta | Atlanta | 32 | Raleigh | NC | NYC | 6-Apr | ||||||
| 1867 | Mar. | 18 | Cosmopolitan | San Francisco | 35 | Atlantic | San Francisco | 30 | Atlanta | GA | NYC | 13-Apr | ||||||
| 1867 | Mar. | 25 | Gate City | Atlanta | 77 | Lookout | Chattanooga | 40 | San Francisco | CA | NYC | 4-May | ||||||
| 1867 | Apr. | 10 | Lone Star | New Orleans | 92 | Dramatic | Mobile | 7 | Dramatic grounds | 9 | Mobile | AL | NYC | 27-Apr | ||||
| 1867 | Apr. | 13 | Athletic | 16 | Eclipse | Chester | 64 | 3 | Chester | PA | NYC | 27-Apr | ||||||
| 1867 | Apr. | 15 | Lone Star | New Orleans | 15 | Southern | New Orleans | 16 | New Orleans | LA | NYC | 27-Apr | ||||||
| 1867 | Apr. | 15 | Eclipse | Chester | 38 | Eclipse | Chester | 38 | Chester | PA | NYC | 27-Apr | ||||||
| 1867 | Apr. | 19 | Enterprise | Brooklyn | 50 | Hamilton | 30 | St. Mark's Place Grounds | 9 | 3 | NY | NYC | 27-Apr | juniors | ||||
| 1867 | Apr. | 20 | Athletic | Philadelphia | 41 | Bachelor | Philadelphia | 11 | 3.1 | Philadelphia | PA | NYC | 27-Apr | |||||
| 1867 | Apr. | 20 | Juniata | 36 | Osceola | 33 | Allegheny | PA | NYC | 27-Apr | ||||||||
| 1867 | Apr. | 26 | Star | New Brunswick | 36 | Star | New Brunswick | 14 | 9 | 3 | New Brunswick | Middlesex County | NJ | NYC | 11-May | |||
| 1867 | Apr. | 27 | National | Washington | 35 | Nautical | Annapolis | 11 | 9 | 2.75 | Annapolis | MD | NYC | 11-May | ||||
| 1867 | Apr. | 27 | Star | Brooklyn | 24 | Independent | Brooklyn | 18 | 9 | 2.33 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 11-May | |||
| 1867 | Apr. | 28 | Empire | New Orleans | 20 | Lone Star | New Orleans | 9 | 1.66 | New Orleans | LA | NYC | 18-May | |||||
| 1867 | May | 1 | Bloomington | Bloomington | 17 | Bloomington | Bloomington | 23 | Bloomington | IL | NYC | 18-May | ||||||
| 1867 | May | 4 | Eclipse | Chester | 34 | Athlete | Chester | 23 | 5 | 2.1 | Chester | PA | NYC | 18-May | ||||
| 1867 | May | 4 | Enterprise | Brooklyn | 52 | Osceola | Brooklyn | 39 | St. Mark's Grounds | 9 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 18-May | juniors | ||
| 1867 | May | 4 | Liberty | Norristown | 39 | Shooting Star | Philadelphia | 32 | Norristown | PA | NYC | 18-May | ||||||
| 1867 | May | 4 | Wapello | Rock Island | 55 | Moline | Moline | 11 | Rock Island | IL | NYC | 8-Jun | ||||||
| 1867 | May | 5 | Harvard | Cambridge | 48 | Beacon | Boston | 20 | Cambridge | MA | NYC | 25-May | ||||||
| 1867 | May | 5 | Omaha | Nebraska | 110 | Fort Calhoun | Fort Calhoun | 50 | Omaha | NE | NYC | 1-Jun | ||||||
| 1867 | May | 6 | National | Troy | 48 | Phil Sheridan | Cohoes | 41 | 9 | Cohoes | NY | NYC | 18-May | |||||
| 1867 | May | 6 | Hornets Nest | Charlotte | 31 | Rip Van Winkle | Concord | 17 | Charlotte | NC | NYC | 18-May | ||||||
| 1867 | May | 7 | Eureka | Newark | 12 | Irvington | Irvington | 17 | 3 | Irvington | NJ | NYC | 18-May | rain | ||||
| 1867 | May | 7 | Osceola | Pittsburgh | 17 | Hamill | Pittsburgh | 15 | Oakland | PA | NYC | 18-May | ||||||
| 1867 | May | 9 | Uncas | 37 | Orion | 33 | 9 | Hoboken | Hudson County | NJ | NYC | 18-May | ||||||
| 1867 | May | 9 | Athletic | Philadelphia | 54 | West Philadelphia | Philadelphia | 14 | 9 | Philadelphia | PA | NYC | 18-May | |||||
| 1867 | May | 9 | Quaker City | Philadelphia | 22 | Camden | Camden | 17 | 5 | Philadelphia | PA | NYC | 18-May | rain | ||||
| 1867 | May | 9 | Union | St. Louis | 31 | Pickwick | St. Louis | 26 | St. Louis | MO | NYC | 18-May | ||||||
| 1867 | May | 10 | Western | Burlington | 39 | Western | Burlington | 14 | Burlington | IA | NYC | 25-May | ||||||
| 1867 | May | 10 | Stark | Canton | 72 | Sippo | Massillon | 25 | OH | NYC | 1-Jun | |||||||
| 1867 | May | 11 | Washington | Pittsburgh | 27 | Expert | Pittsburgh | 24 | Brownstone Commons | Pittsburgh | PA | NYC | 18-May | |||||
| 1867 | May | 11 | Leader | Pittsburgh | 57 | Star of the West | Pittsburgh | 24 | Pittsburgh | PA | NYC | 18-May | ||||||
| 1867 | May | 11 | Gray and Green Co. | New York | 41 | Bradstreet Press | New York | 16 | New York | Manhattan | NY | NYC | 18-May | |||||
| 1867 | May | 11 | Meers | Steubenville | 89 | Hygeia | Pittsburgh | 61 | Steubenville | OH | NYC | 18-May | ||||||
| 1867 | May | 11 | Buckeye | Cincinnati | 49 | Holt Base Ball | Newport | 14 | Union Cricket Grounds | 9 | 2 | Cincinnati | OH | NYC | 25-May | |||
| 1867 | May | 11 | Harvard | Cambridge | 67 | Granite | Holliston | 26 | 9 | Cambridge | MA | NYC | 25-May | |||||
| 1867 | May | 11 | Omaha | Nebraska | 61 | North Western | Council Bluffs | 29 | 9 | Council Bluffs | IA | NYC | 1-Jun | |||||
| 1867 | May | 13 | Athletic | Philadelphia | 34 | West Philadelphia | Philadelphia | 13 | 9 | 4.1 | Philadelphia | PA | NYC | 25-May | ||||
| 1867 | May | 15 | Lowell | Boston | 37 | Harvard | Cambridge | 28 | Boston Common | 9 | 2.84 | Boston | MA | NYC | 1-Jun | |||
| 1867 | May | 15 | Eclipse | Chester | 56 | Eclipse | Chester | 35 | Chester | PA | NYC | 8-Jun | ||||||
| 1867 | May | 16 | Eureka | Newark | 17 | Irvington | Irvington | 25 | 9 | 2.75 | Irvington | NJ | NYC | 25-May | ||||
| 1867 | May | 16 | Union | Lansingburgh | 53 | Hudson Vale | Lansingburgh | 16 | Lansingburgh | NY | NYC | 25-May | ||||||
| 1867 | May | 16 | Crescent | St. Albans | 16 | Crescent | St. Albans | 4 | St. Albans | VT | NYC | 25-May | ||||||
| 1867 | May | 16 | Hiawatha | Kittanning | 43 | Vulcan | Brady's Bend | 29 | Brady's Bend | PA | NYC | 1-Jun | ||||||
| 1867 | May | 16 | Athlete | Chester | 32 | Blackstone | 7 | Chester | PA | NYC | 8-Jun | |||||||
| 1867 | May | 16 | Athlete | Chester | 55 | Blackstone | 11 | Chester | PA | NYC | 8-Jun | |||||||
| 1867 | May | 16 | Custer | Ionia | 12 | Wolverine | Ionia | 17 | Ionia | MI | NYC | 8-Jun | ||||||
| 1867 | May | 17 | Athletic | Philadelphia | 19 | Keystone | Philadelphia | 14 | 9 | 3.5 | Camden | NJ | NYC | 25-May | ||||
| 1867 | May | 17 | Lowell | Boston | 47 | Chemung | Stoughton | 18 | Boston | MA | NYC | 1-Jun | ||||||
| 1867 | May | 18 | Union | Morrisania | 48 | Atlanta | 10 | 9 | 2.66 | Morrisania | The Bronx | NY | NYC | 25-May | ||||
| 1867 | May | 18 | Bradstreet Press | New York | 46 | Gray and Green Co. | New York | 27 | 9 | New York | Manhattan | NY | NYC | 25-May | ||||
| 1867 | May | 18 | Upton | Upton | 27 | Lowell | Boston | 13 | Boston Common | 7 | Boston | MA | NYC | 1-Jun | Jrs. And 2nd nines | |||
| 1867 | May | 18 | Enterprise | Brooklyn | 42 | Osceola | Brooklyn | 32 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 1-Jun | |||||
| 1867 | May | 18 | Excelsior | Chicago | 39 | Atlantic Jr. | Chicago | 19 | Chicago | IL | NYC | 1-Jun | ||||||
| 1867 | May | 18 | Excelsior | Chicago | 28 | Excelsior | Chicago | 17 | Chicago | IL | NYC | 1-Jun | ||||||
| 1867 | May | 19 | Severn | Annapolis | 29 | Nautical | Annapolis | 23 | Annapolis | MD | NYC | 8-Jun | ||||||
| 1867 | May | 20 | Moline | Moline | 29 | Wapello | Rock Island | 29 | Moline | IL | NYC | 8-Jun | ||||||
| 1867 | May | 21 | Mountain City | Chattanooga | 52 | Gate City | Atlanta | 71 | Chattanooga | TN | NYC | 8-Jun | ||||||
| 1867 | May | 22 | Wapello | Rock Island | 32 | Moline | Moline | 27 | Rock Island | IL | NYC | 8-Jun | ||||||
| 1867 | May | 23 | Eureka | Newark | 66 | Star | New Brunswick | 9 | 9 | New Brunswick | Middlesex County | NJ | NYC | 1-Jun | ||||
| 1867 | May | 23 | Quaker City | Philadelphia | 48 | Alvin | Philadelphia | 12 | 6 | 2.84 | Philadelphia | PA | NYC | 8-Jun | ||||
| 1867 | May | 23 | Excelsior Jr. | Brooklyn | 34 | Alert Club of Seton Hall | South Orange | 21 | 9 | 2.5 | South Orange | Essex County | NJ | NYC | 8-Jun | |||
| 1867 | May | 23 | Oriental | Brooklyn | 37 | Eclectic | Brooklyn | 34 | 9 | 2.75 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 8-Jun | |||
| 1867 | May | 23 | Western | Indianapolis | 56 | Indianapolis | Indianapolis | 14 | Indianapolis | IN | NYC | 8-Jun | ||||||
| 1867 | May | 24 | Harvard | Cambridge | 32 | Lowell | Boston | 20 | Cambridge | MA | NYC | 1-Jun | ||||||
| 1867 | May | 24 | North Star | St. Paul | 56 | Minneapolis | Minneapolis | 26 | Minneapolis | MN | NYC | 22-Jun | ||||||
| 1867 | May | 25 | Union | Morrisania | 101 | Athlete | Washington Heights | 13 | 6 | Morrisania | The Bronx | NY | NYC | 1-Jun | ||||
| 1867 | May | 25 | Gray and Green Co. | New York | 57 | Bradstreet Press | New York | 6 | Mutual Grouns | New York | Manhattan | NY | NYC | 1-Jun | ||||
| 1867 | May | 25 | Hoole & Chambers | Pittsburgh | 50 | Leader | Pittsburgh | 17 | Oakland | PA | NYC | 1-Jun | ||||||
| 1867 | May | 25 | Old Point | Fortress Monroe | 80 | Stonewall | Norfolk | 26 | Norfolk | VA | NYC | 8-Jun | ||||||
| 1867 | May | 25 | Garden City | Chicago | 33 | Resolute | Chicago | 24 | Chicago | IL | NYC | 8-Jun | ||||||
| 1867 | May | 25 | Sheridan | Fortress Monroe | 18 | Ordnance | Fortress Monroe | 14 | 9 | 2.75 | Old Point | VA | NYC | 8-Jun | ||||
| 1867 | May | 25 | Independent Base Ball | Brooklyn | 39 | Powhatan | Brooklyn | 35 | 9 | 3 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 8-Jun | |||
| 1867 | May | 25 | Cincinnati | Cincinnati | 82 | Buckeye | Cincinnati | 40 | Cincinnati | OH | NYC | 8-Jun | ||||||
| 1867 | May | 27 | Quaker City | Philadelphia | 40 | West Philadelphia | Philadelphia | 13 | 9 | 3.25 | Philadelphia | PA | NYC | 8-Jun | ||||
| 1867 | May | 27 | Eclectic | Brooklyn | 32 | Americus | Newark | 17 | 9 | 1.75 | Newark | Essex County | NJ | NYC | 8-Jun | |||
| 1867 | May | 28 | Ninth Nat. Bank | 41 | Am. Exchange Bank | 18 | Jersey City | Hudson County | NJ | NYC | 8-Jun | |||||||
| 1867 | May | 28 | Alert | Heidelberg College | 100 | Clinton | Tiffin | 36 | Tiffin | OH | NYC | 15-Jun | ||||||
| 1867 | May | 29 | Criterion | Boston | 32 | Eureka | South Boston | 28 | Boston | MA | NYC | 8-Jun | ||||||
| 1867 | May | 29 | Eon | Portland | 53 | Crescent | Saccarappa | 29 | Saccarappa | ME | NYC | 8-Jun | ||||||
| 1867 | May | 29 | Atlantic | Buffalo | 63 | Arctic | Buffalo | 6 | Buffalo | NY | NYC | 15-Jun | ||||||
| 1867 | May | 29 | Atlantic | Brooklyn | 27 | Eckford | Brooklyn | 14 | Union Grounds | 9 | 2.1 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 29-Jun | ||
| 1867 | May | 30 | Active | Newark | 16 | Irvington | Irvington | 25 | 9 | 2.66 | Newark | Essex County | NJ | NYC | 8-Jun | |||
| 1867 | May | 30 | Oneida | Boston | 22 | Franklin | Boston | 10 | Boston Common | Boston | MA | NYC | 8-Jun | |||||
| 1867 | May | 30 | Eureka | South Boston | 34 | Hamilton | Boston | 24 | Boston Common | Boston | MA | NYC | 8-Jun | |||||
| 1867 | May | 30 | Norfolk | 41 | Warren | 9 | Roxbury | MA | NYC | 8-Jun | ||||||||
| 1867 | May | 30 | Wyoming | Melrose | 32 | Washington | Malden | 25 | Malden | MA | NYC | 8-Jun | ||||||
| 1867 | May | 30 | Pioneer | Pittsburgh | 55 | Abel | 10 | Pittsburgh | PA | NYC | 8-Jun | |||||||
| 1867 | May | 30 | Independent | Waterford | 19 | Unknown | Cohoes | 13 | Cohoes | NY | NYC | 8-Jun | ||||||
| 1867 | May | 31 | Western | Indianapolis | 47 | Blue River | Knightstown | 15 | IN | NYC | 15-Jun | |||||||
| 1867 | May | 31 | Winthrop | Quincy | 39 | Active | Boston | 33 | Boston Common | Boston | MA | NYC | 15-Jun | |||||
| 1867 | May | Niagara | Brownstown | 20 | Triumph | Allegheny | 18 | Allegheny | PA | NYC | 18-May | |||||||
| 1867 | May | Triumph | Allegheny | 24 | Niagara | Brownstown | 10 | Allegheny | PA | NYC | 18-May | |||||||
| 1867 | June | 1 | Lowell | Boston | 28 | Harvard | Cambridge | 39 | 9 | 3.25 | Medford | MA | NYC | 8-Jun | ||||
| 1867 | June | 1 | Baltic | Cincinnati | 39 | Atlantic | Cincinnati | 7 | Cincinnati | OH | NYC | 15-Jun | ||||||
| 1867 | June | 1 | Copec | Covington | 46 | Minneola | Newport | 40 | Newport | KY | NYC | 15-Jun | ||||||
| 1867 | June | 1 | Atlantic | Indianapolis | 27 | Archiel | Indianapolis | 20 | Indianapolis | IN | NYC | 15-Jun | ||||||
| 1867 | June | 1 | Buckeye | Cincinnati | 43 | Buckeye | Dayton | 28 | Dayton | OH | NYC | 15-Jun | ||||||
| 1867 | June | 1 | Enterprise Jr. | Brooklyn | 42 | Undaunted Jr. | Brooklyn | 8 | Oriental grounds | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 15-Jun | ||||
| 1867 | June | 1 | Eagle | Andover | 44 | Alert | Andover | 30 | Andover | MA | NYC | 15-Jun | ||||||
| 1867 | June | 1 | Old Point | Fortress Monroe | 39 | Creighton | Norfolk | 24 | Norfolk | VA | NYC | 22-Jun | ||||||
| 1867 | June | 1 | Ordnance | Fortress Monroe | 38 | Sheridan | Fortress Monroe | 35 | Fortress Monroe | VA | NYC | 22-Jun | ||||||
| 1867 | June | 2 | Putnam Jr. | Brooklyn | 25 | Liberty Jr. | Brooklyn | 17 | Fordham | The Bronx | NY | NYC | 15-Jun | |||||
| 1867 | June | 2 | Empire | New Orleans | 23 | Southern | New Orleans | 26 | Delachaise Grounds | New Orleans | LA | NYC | 29-Jun | |||||
| 1867 | June | 4 | Union | Morrisania | 17 | Irvington | Irvington | 26 | 9 | 2.75 | Irvington | NJ | NYC | 15-Jun | ||||
| 1867 | June | 4 | Putnam | Troy | 33 | Independent | Troy | 29 | Troy | NY | NYC | 15-Jun | ||||||
| 1867 | June | 4 | Kleinfelder's Side | Philadelphia | 23 | Pratt's Side | Philadelphia | 66 | Athletic's Grounds | 9 | 3.5 | Philadelphia | PA | NYC | 22-Jun | |||
| 1867 | June | 4 | Union | Elmira | 41 | Excelsior | Elmira | 39 | Elmira | NY | NYC | 22-Jun | ||||||
| 1867 | June | 5 | Old Point | Fortress Monroe | 40 | Creighton | Norfolk | 27 | Fortress Monroe | VA | NYC | 22-Jun | ||||||
| 1867 | June | 6 | Athletic | Savannah Academy | 79 | Washington | Ashland | 33 | OH | NYC | 22-Jun | |||||||
| 1867 | June | 7 | Ontario | Oswego | 42 | Frontier | Oswego | 30 | Oswego | NY | NYC | 22-Jun | ||||||
| 1867 | June | 8 | Mutual | New York | 22 | Independent Base Ball | Brooklyn | 1 | Union Grounds | 4 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 15-Jun | rain | ||
| 1867 | June | 9 | Reveille | Greenville | 60 | Jackson | Greenville | 45 | 9 | Greenville | LA | NYC | 29-Jun | |||||
| 1867 | June | 10 | Keystone | Philadelphia | 51 | Quaker City | Philadelphia | 25 | Keystone Grounds | 9 | Camden | NJ | NYC | 22-Jun | ||||
| 1867 | June | 10 | Farmer | Philadelphia | 49 | Pacific | Philadelphia | 19 | 5 | Philadelphia | PA | NYC | 22-Jun | |||||
| 1867 | June | 10 | Govan | 44 | Towson | Towson | 36 | Towson | MD | NYC | 22-Jun | |||||||
| 1867 | June | 11 | Union | Morrisania | 26 | Eureka | Newark | 12 | 9 | 2.66 | Newark | Essex County | NJ | NYC | 22-Jun | |||
| 1867 | June | 11 | Athletic | Philadelphia | 88 | Eon | Portland | 23 | Boston Common | 9 | 3.1 | Boston | MA | NYC | 22-Jun | |||
| 1867 | June | 11 | Continental | Jersey City | 17 | Magnolia | 16 | Jersey City | Hudson County | NJ | NYC | 22-Jun | ||||||
| 1867 | June | 11 | Dartmouth | Darmouth College | 36 | Amherst College | Amherst | 24 | Amherst | MA | NYC | 29-Jun | ||||||
| 1867 | June | 11 | Picked Nine | Louisville | 26 | Louisville | Louisville | 21 | Louisville | KY | NYC | 29-Jun | ||||||
| 1867 | June | 12 | Athletic | Philadelphia | 22 | Harvard | Cambridge | 10 | Boston Common | 9 | 2.25 | Boston | MA | NYC | 22-Jun | |||
| 1867 | June | 12 | Mutual | New York | 58 | Jefferson | New York | 1 | Union Grounds | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 22-Jun | ||||
| 1867 | June | 12 | Creighton | Washington | 40 | Emerson | Washington | 13 | Washington | DC | NYC | 22-Jun | ||||||
| 1867 | June | 13 | Athletic | Philadelphia | 53 | Lowell | Boston | 8 | Boston Common | 5 | Boston | MA | NYC | 22-Jun | ||||
| 1867 | June | 13 | Clipper | Jersey City | 31 | Marietta | 21 | Jersey City | Hudson County | NJ | NYC | 22-Jun | ||||||
| 1867 | June | 13 | Mountaineer | Ebensburg | 73 | Kickenpawling | Johnstown | 50 | Ebensburg | PA | NYC | 29-Jun | ||||||
| 1867 | June | 13 | Severn | Annapolis | 32 | Creighton | Norfolk | 11 | Norfolk | VA | NYC | 29-Jun | ||||||
| 1867 | June | 13 | Advance | Cumberland | 69 | Alert | Cumberland | 51 | Cumberland | MD | NYC | 29-Jun | ||||||
| 1867 | June | 14 | North Star | St. Paul | 47 | Minneapolis | Minneapolis | 29 | St. Paul | MN | NYC | 29-Jun | ||||||
| 1867 | June | 14 | Athletic | Philadelphia | 35 | Charter Oak | Hartford | 19 | 9 | 3.33 | Hartford | CT | NYC | 29-Jun | ||||
| 1867 | June | 15 | Mountaineer | Ebensburg | 30 | Mountain | Altoona | 22 | Altoona | PA | NYC | 29-Jun | ||||||
| 1867 | June | 15 | Palisades | Englewood | 36 | Anneke Jane | New York | 16 | Englewood | Bergen County | NJ | NYC | 29-Jun | |||||
| 1867 | June | 15 | Arctic | Chicago | 38 | Economy | Chicago | 49 | Chicago | IL | NYC | 29-Jun | ||||||
| 1867 | June | 15 | Hiawatha | Kittanning | 28 | Eureka | Kittaning | 25 | Kittaning | PA | NYC | 29-Jun | juniors | |||||
| 1867 | June | 15 | Upton | Boston | 30 | Beacon | Boston | 29 | Boston Common | 9 | 3.33 | Boston | MA | NYC | 29-Jun | juniors | ||
| 1867 | June | 15 | Excelsior | Brooklyn | 32 | Independent Base Ball | Brooklyn | 9 | Capitoline Grounds | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 29-Jun | ||||
| 1867 | June | 15 | Union | Morrisania | 45 | Eclectic | New York | 10 | Morrisania | The Bronx | NY | NYC | 29-Jun | |||||
| 1867 | June | 15 | Enterprise | 24 | Alert | 12 | 9 | Andover | MA | NYC | 29-Jun | |||||||
| 1867 | June | 15 | Union | Titusville | 31 | Independent | Titusville | 12 | 9 | Titusville | PA | NYC | 29-Jun | |||||
| 1867 | June | 15 | University | Ann Arbor | 70 | Detroit | Detroit | 18 | 9 | Ann Arbor | MI | NYC | 29-Jun | |||||
| 1867 | June | 16 | Atlantic | Buffalo | 30 | Ellsworth | Buffalo | 11 | Buffalo | NY | NYC | 29-Jun | ||||||
| 1867 | June | 16 | Alert | Washington | 21 | Pythian | Philadelphia | 18 | 5 | Philadelphia | PA | NYC | 13-Jul | rain | ||||
| 1867 | June | 17 | Alpha | Salem | 92 | Chelsea | Chelsea | 37 | Salem | MA | NYC | 29-Jun | cricket? | |||||
| 1867 | June | 19 | Mutual | New York | 32 | Eclectic | Brooklyn | 5 | 9 | 1.75 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 29-Jun | |||
| 1867 | June | 19 | Marion | Brooklyn | 32 | Montauk | Brooklyn | 29 | Greenpoint | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 29-Jun | ||||
| 1867 | June | 19 | Franklin | Brooklyn | 22 | Adriatic | New York | 20 | 9 | NY | NYC | 29-Jun | ||||||
| 1867 | June | 19 | Dirigo | Westbrook | 43 | Rising Star | Portland | 27 | Westbrook | ME | NYC | 6-Jul | ||||||
| 1867 | June | 19 | Excelsior | Paducah | 68 | Quickstep | Paducah | 48 | Paducah | KY | NYC | 6-Jul | ||||||
| 1867 | June | 20 | Quaker City | Philadelphia | 29 | Bachelor | Philadelphia | 6 | 9 | 2.4 | Philadelphia | PA | NYC | 29-Jun | ||||
| 1867 | June | 20 | Orion | 19 | Hudson | 26 | 9 | Hoboken | Hudson County | NJ | NYC | 29-Jun | ||||||
| 1867 | June | 20 | Continental | Brooklyn | 41 | Oceana | Brooklyn | 18 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 29-Jun | |||||
| 1867 | June | 20 | Diamond | 36 | Orchard | 31 | Hoboken | Hudson County | NJ | NYC | 29-Jun | juniors | ||||||
| 1867 | June | 20 | Alert | Cumberland | 72 | Advance | Cumberland | 18 | Cumberland | MD | NYC | 6-Jul | ||||||
| 1867 | June | 21 | Tri-Mountain | Boston | 38 | King Philip | Abington | 14 | Boston Common | 9 | 2.5 | Boston | MA | NYC | 29-Jun | |||
| 1867 | June | 21 | Chester | Chester | 23 | Alpha | Springfield | 15 | Chester | VT | NYC | 29-Jun | ||||||
| 1867 | June | 21 | Pioneer | Alexandria | 68 | Mount Vernon | Alexandria | 25 | Alexandria | VA | NYC | 6-Jul | ||||||
| 1867 | June | 22 | Frank Leslie | New York | 23 | Point Comfort | Greenville | 19 | 9 | Hunter's Point | Queens | NY | NYC | 6-Jul | ||||
| 1867 | June | 22 | Phillips Academy | Andover | 33 | Phillips Academy | Andover | 32 | 9 | Andover | NY | NYC | 6-Jul | |||||
| 1867 | June | 22 | Lawrence | Spuyten Devil | 40 | Brown | Williamsbridge | 34 | Williamsbridge | NY | NYC | 6-Jul | ||||||
| 1867 | June | 22 | Capitol | Jefferson City | 81 | Empire | Sedalia | 58 | Sedalia | MO | NYC | 6-Jul | ||||||
| 1867 | June | 24 | Quaker City | Philadelphia | 20 | West Philadelphia | Philadelphia | 11 | 9 | 2.4 | Philadelphia | PA | NYC | 6-Jul | ||||
| 1867 | June | 24 | Sheridan | Boston | 32 | Winona | Medford | 16 | 9 | 3.25 | Medford | MA | NYC | 6-Jul | ||||
| 1867 | June | 25 | Phillips Academy | Andover | 22 | Phillips Academy | Andover | 20 | Andover | MA | NYC | 15-Jun | ||||||
| 1867 | June | 25 | Pioneer | Alexandria | 30 | Old Dominion | Alexandria | 21 | 9 | 3 | Alexandria | VA | NYC | 6-Jul | ||||
| 1867 | June | 26 | Clipper | Lowell | 30 | Rolleston | Fitchburg | 11 | MA | NYC | 29-Jun | |||||||
| 1867 | June | 26 | Enterprise | Andover | 41 | Lawrence | Lawrence | 30 | 8 | Andover | MA | NYC | 6-Jul | |||||
| 1867 | June | 27 | Diamond State | Wilmington | 26 | Wawasset | Wilmington | 36 | 9 | Wilmington | DE | NYC | 6-Jul | |||||
| 1867 | June | 27 | Wright's Side | Washington | 9 | Williams' Side | Washington | 21 | 9 | 1.9 | Washington | DC | NYC | 6-Jul | ||||
| 1867 | June | 28 | Mutual | New York | 17 | Irvington | Irvington | 16 | 9 | 3 | Irvington | Essex County | NJ | NYC | 6-Jul | |||
| 1867 | June | 28 | Knickerbocker | St. Albans | 43 | Active | Swanton | 60 | VT | NYC | 13-Jul | |||||||
| 1867 | June | 28 | Forest City | Cleveland | 36 | Western Reserve | Hudson | 37 | 9 | 3.8 | Cleveland | OH | NYC | 13-Jul | ||||
| 1867 | June | 29 | Gray and Greene | New York | 37 | Typographical | Brooklyn | 29 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 6-Jul | |||||
| 1867 | June | 29 | Philadelphia | Philadelphia | 7 | Athletic | Philadelphia | 72 | 9 | 3 | Philadelphia | PA | NYC | 6-Jul | ||||
| 1867 | June | 29 | Mutual | New York | 28 | Independent Base Ball | Brooklyn | 26 | Union of Morrisania | 9 | Morrisania | The Bronx | NY | NYC | 6-Jul | |||
| 1867 | June | 29 | Union | Morrisania | 36 | Eclectic | New York | 32 | Red House | 9 | 2.84 | New York | Manhattan | NY | NYC | 6-Jul | ||
| 1867 | June | 29 | Gymnastic | Washington | 106 | Interior | Washington | 29 | Washington | DC | NYC | 13-Jul | ||||||
| 1867 | June | 29 | Peconic | South Brooklyn | 48 | Enterprise | Clifton, Staten Island | 30 | Clifton | Staten Island | NY | NYC | 13-Jul | |||||
| 1867 | June | 29 | Eagle | St. Albans | 36 | Scranton | Scranton | 14 | VT | NYC | 13-Jul | |||||||
| 1867 | June | Nautical | New Bedford | 18 | Nautical | New Bedford | 7 | New Bedford | MA | NYC | 22-Jun | |||||||
| 1867 | June | Mutual | Columbia | 40 | Columbia | Columbia | 23 | 9 | Columbia | PA | NYC | 29-Jun | ||||||
| 1867 | June | Quaker City | Philadelphia | 95 | Alvin | Philadelphia | 18 | Philadelphia | PA | NYC | 29-Jun | |||||||
| 1867 | June | Oakland | Needham | 29 | Eagle | Medfield | 12 | Medfield | MA | NYC | 29-Jun | |||||||
| 1867 | June | Nashville | Nashville | 42 | Stonewall | Nashville | 25 | Nashville | TN | NYC | 6-Jul | |||||||
| 1867 | July | 1 | Keystone | Philadelphia | 42 | Quaker City | Philadelphia | 37 | 9 | 4.5 | Philadelphia | PA | NYC | 13-Jul | ||||
| 1867 | July | 1 | Picked Nine | Baltimore | 60 | Picked Nine | Baltimore | 24 | Baltimore | MD | NYC | 13-Jul | ||||||
| 1867 | July | 1 | Eclipse | Westchester | 51 | Olympic | Pittsburgh | 29 | West Common | Allegheny | PA | NYC | 13-Jul | |||||
| 1867 | July | 1 | Defiance | Cleveland | 60 | Dramatic | Cleveland | 57 | 9 | Cleveland | OH | NYC | 13-Jul | |||||
| 1867 | July | 2 | Union | St. Louis | 59 | Empire | St. Louis | 29 | 9 | St. Louis | MO | NYC | 13-Jul | |||||
| 1867 | July | 2 | National | Washington | 74 | Continental | Washington | 26 | Washington | DC | NYC | 13-Jul | ||||||
| 1867 | July | 2 | Union | Morrisania | 22 | Irvington | Irvington | 26 | Union of Morrisania | 9 | 3 | Melrose | The Bronx | NY | NYC | 13-Jul | ||
| 1867 | July | 3 | Athletic | Philadelphia | 54 | Harry Clay | Philadelphia | 6 | 9 | Philadelphia | PA | NYC | 13-Jul | |||||
| 1867 | July | 3 | Niagara | Buffalo | 25 | Auburn | Auburn | 24 | 9 | Auburn | NY | NYC | 13-Jul | |||||
| 1867 | July | 3 | Pequot | New London | 44 | Charter Oak | Hartford | 34 | 9 | New Haven | CT | NYC | 13-Jul | |||||
| 1867 | July | 3 | Allegheny | Allegheny | 45 | Stark | Canton | 13 | 6 | 1.5 | Canton | OH | NYC | 13-Jul | rain | |||
| 1867 | July | 4 | Quaker City | Philadelphia | 85 | Leonore | Philadelphia | 11 | 6 | 3.66 | Philadelphia | PA | NYC | 13-Jul | ||||
| 1867 | July | 4 | Athletic | Philadelphia | 66 | Atlantic | Trenton | 8 | 9 | Trenton | NJ | NYC | 13-Jul | |||||
| 1867 | July | 4 | Irvington | Irvington | 36 | Neptune | Easton | 16 | 9 | Easton | PA | NYC | 13-Jul | |||||
| 1867 | July | 4 | Clifton | Buffalo | 19 | Auburn | Auburn | 19 | 5 | Auburn | NY | NYC | 13-Jul | dark | ||||
| 1867 | July | 4 | Maryland | Baltimore | 61 | Jefferson | Washington | 50 | Baltimore | MD | NYC | 13-Jul | ||||||
| 1867 | July | 4 | Alert | Baltimore | 38 | Baltimore | Baltimore | 25 | Baltimore | MD | NYC | 13-Jul | ||||||
| 1867 | July | 4 | Calvert | Baltimore | 68 | Havre de Grace | Havre de Grace | 21 | Havre de Grace | MD | NYC | 13-Jul | ||||||
| 1867 | July | 4 | Independent | Baltimore | 25 | Patapsco | Baltimore | 39 | Locust Point | Baltimore | MD | NYC | 13-Jul | |||||
| 1867 | July | 4 | National | Dorchester | 51 | Granite | Milton | 26 | MA | NYC | 13-Jul | |||||||
| 1867 | July | 4 | Active | Chelsea | 54 | Everett | Brighton | 20 | Brighton | MA | NYC | 13-Jul | ||||||
| 1867 | July | 4 | Union | Morrisania | 54 | Alert | 11 | 5 | 1.84 | Melrose | The Bronx | NY | NYC | 13-Jul | ||||
| 1867 | July | 4 | Mountaineer | Ebensburg | 43 | Mountain | Altoona | 32 | 3.25 | Altoona | PA | NYC | 13-Jul | |||||
| 1867 | July | 4 | Mutual | East Liberty | 36 | Anchor | Swissvale | 32 | PA | NYC | 13-Jul | |||||||
| 1867 | July | 4 | Creighton | Washington | 53 | Star | Laurel | 19 | Washington | DC | NYC | 13-Jul | ||||||
| 1867 | July | 4 | Monumental | Washington | 28 | Tecumseh | Washington | 13 | Washington | DC | NYC | 13-Jul | ||||||
| 1867 | July | 4 | Mutual | New York | 20 | Eckford | Brooklyn | 20 | Union Grounds | 9 | 2.3 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 13-Jul | ||
| 1867 | July | 4 | Atlantic | Brooklyn | 39 | Star | Brooklyn | 21 | Union Grounds | 9 | 2.6 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 13-Jul | ||
| 1867 | July | 4 | Harlem Jr. | Harlem | 58 | Dexter | Brooklyn | 38 | Mount Morris Square | Harlem | Manhattan | NY | NYC | 13-Jul | juniors | |||
| 1867 | July | 4 | Monitor | Lincoln | 49 | Athletic | Springfield | 40 | Springfield | IL | NYC | 20-Jul | ||||||
| 1867 | July | 4 | Capitol | Springfield | 39 | Union | Jacksonville | 18 | Springfield | IL | NYC | 20-Jul | ||||||
| 1867 | July | 4 | Mutual | Albany | 36 | Grammercy | New York | 21 | 9 | Albany | NY | NYC | 20-Jul | |||||
| 1867 | July | 4 | Hope | New York | 27 | Hudson | New York | 44 | 9 | Hoboken | Hudson County | NJ | NYC | 27-Jul | ||||
| 1867 | July | 4 | Sheridan | Cohoes | 29 | Hope | Cohoes | 27 | Cohoes | NY | NYC | 27-Jul | ||||||
| 1867 | July | 4 | Clipper | Lowell | 48 | Lawrence | Lawrence | 28 | Fair Grounds | 7 | MA | NYC | 27-Jul | |||||
| 1867 | July | 5 | Arctic | Philadelphia | 55 | Keystone | Philadelphia | 35 | 9 | Camden | NJ | NYC | 13-Jul | |||||
| 1867 | July | 5 | Tri-Mountain | Boston | 67 | Shield | East Cambridge | 35 | Boston | MA | NYC | 13-Jul | ||||||
| 1867 | July | 5 | Sheridan | Cohoes | 52 | National | Troy | 19 | NY | NYC | 27-Jul | |||||||
| 1867 | July | 6 | Erie | Baltimore | 41 | Ivanhoe | Baltimore | 41 | Baltimore | MD | NYC | 13-Jul | ||||||
| 1867 | July | 6 | Buena Vista | Brooklyn | 27 | Rival | New York | 8 | Hoboken | Hudson County | NJ | NYC | 27-Jul | juniors | ||||
| 1867 | July | 8 | Bachelor | Philadelphia | 18 | Arctic | Philadelphia | 14 | 5 | Philadelphia | NYC | 20-Jul | ||||||
| 1867 | July | 8 | Union | Morrisania | 41 | National | Albany | 17 | Albany | NYC | 20-Jul | |||||||
| 1867 | July | 9 | Union | Morrisania | 23 | Union | Lansingburgh | 51 | Troy | NYC | 20-Jul | |||||||
| 1867 | July | 9 | Enterprise | Cincinnati | 71 | Minneola | Newport | 40 | Newport | KY | NYC | 20-Jul | ||||||
| 1867 | July | 9 | Atlantic | Brooklyn | 11 | Eckford | Brooklyn | 4 | Union Grounds | 6 | 1.5 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 20-Jul | rain | |
| 1867 | July | 9 | Lincoln | Pittsburgh | 38 | Hiawatha | Kittanning | 32 | Kittanning | PA | NYC | 10-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | July | 10 | Niagara | Buffalo | 62 | Active | Buffalo | 12 | Buffalo | NYC | 20-Jul | |||||||
| 1867 | July | 10 | Atlantic | Buffalo | 51 | Star | Black Rock | 35 | Buffalo | NYC | 20-Jul | |||||||
| 1867 | July | 10 | Union | Morrisania | 49 | Utica | Utica | 26 | Utica | NYC | 20-Jul | |||||||
| 1867 | July | 10 | Eckford | Brooklyn | 47 | Mutual | Brooklyn | 12 | Union Grounds | 9 | 2.16 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 27-Jul | 2nd nines | |
| 1867 | July | 10 | North Star | St. Paul | 57 | Frontier | Mankato | 14 | Mankato | MN | NYC | 27-Jul | ||||||
| 1867 | July | 10 | Battery | New York | 61 | Olive | Newark | 29 | Williamsburg | 6 | 2.16 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 27-Jul | ||
| 1867 | July | 10 | Union | St. Louis | 34 | Empire | St. Louis | 32 | 9 | St. Louis | MO | NYC | 27-Jul | |||||
| 1867 | July | 11 | Oriental | Brooklyn | 53 | Empire | New York | 10 | Greenpoint | 9 | 2.5 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NYC | 20-Jul | |||
| 1867 | July | 11 | Quaker City | Philadelphia | 70 | Arctic | Philadelphia | 26 | 9 | 2.5 | Philadelphia | NYC | 20-Jul | |||||
| 1867 | July | 11 | Union | Morrisania | 34 | Excelsior | Rochester | 15 | Rochester | NYC | 20-Jul | |||||||
| 1867 | July | 11 | Enterprise | Baltimore | 28 | Pastime | Baltimore | 46 | 9 | Baltimore | MD | NYC | 27-Jul | |||||
| 1867 | July | 11 | Prairie City | Ripon | 31 | Berlin City | Berlin | 27 | WI | NYC | 27-Jul | |||||||
| 1867 | July | 12 | Mutual | New York | 28 | Eckford | Brooklyn | 9 | Union Grounds | 6 | 1.9 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NYC | 20-Jul | rain | ||
| 1867 | July | 12 | Union | Morrisania | 25 | Niagara | Buffalo | 19 | Buffalo | NYC | 20-Jul | |||||||
| 1867 | July | 12 | Cayuga | Itasca | 17 | Canadilla | Itasca | 16 | Itasca | NY | NYC | 27-Jul | ||||||
| 1867 | July | 13 | National | Washington | 90 | Capitol | Columbus | 10 | Columbus | OH | NYC | 20-Jul | ||||||
| 1867 | July | 13 | Frank Leslie | New York | 81 | New York Printing | New York | 32 | Burnside Grounds | 9 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 27-Jul | |||
| 1867 | July | 13 | Atlantic | Chicago | 41 | Garden City | Chicago | 32 | 9 | Chicago | IL | NYC | 27-Jul | |||||
| 1867 | July | 13 | Palisades | Englewood | 73 | Alert | English Neighborhood | 60 | 9 | Englewood | Bergen County | NJ | NYC | 27-Jul | Palisades 2nd nine | |||
| 1867 | July | 13 | Clipper | Castleton | 70 | Middlebury College | Middlebury | 49 | Castleton | VT | NYC | 27-Jul | ||||||
| 1867 | July | 13 | Bedford | Chelsea | 40 | Hopeful | Charlestown | 21 | 9 | Charlestown | MA | NYC | 27-Jul | |||||
| 1867 | July | 13 | Mohawk | Brooklyn | 24 | Star | Brooklyn | 46 | Union Grounds | 9 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 27-Jul | |||
| 1867 | July | 13 | Kickenepawling | Johnstown | 39 | Mountaineer | Ebensburg | 27 | Johnstown | PA | NYC | 27-Jul | ||||||
| 1867 | July | 13 | Meteor | New Hartford | 19 | Dexter | Winsted | 18 | Pine Meadow | New Hartford | CT | NYC | 27-Jul | |||||
| 1867 | July | 15 | Daily Times | New York | 62 | Lithographers | New York | 35 | 7 | 3.75 | NY | NYC | 27-Jul | |||||
| 1867 | July | 15 | Quaker City | Philadelphia | 50 | Bachelor | Philadelphia | 14 | 9 | 2.16 | Philadelphia | PA | NYC | 27-Jul | ||||
| 1867 | July | 15 | Mutual | Albany | 41 | Chatham | Chatham Four Corners | 20 | 3 | Chatham Four | NY | NYC | 27-Jul | |||||
| 1867 | July | 15 | Pequot | New London | 48 | New Britain | New Britain | 47 | 9 | 3.84 | New London | CT | NYC | 27-Jul | ||||
| 1867 | July | 15 | Eagle | San Francisco | 73 | Cosmopolitan | San Francisco | 24 | 9 | 3 | San Francisco | CA | NYC | 27-Jul | ||||
| 1867 | July | 15 | Sheridan | Cohoes | 79 | McClellan | Waterford | 32 | NY | NYC | 27-Jul | |||||||
| 1867 | July | 15 | Athletic | Philadelphia | 118 | Tyrolean | Harrisburg | 11 | 9 | Harrisburg | PA | NYC | 27-Jul | |||||
| 1867 | July | 15 | National | Washington | 53 | Cincinnati | Cincinnati | 10 | Cincinnati | OH | NYC | 27-Jul | ||||||
| 1867 | July | 15 | Iron | Johnstown | 35 | Kickenapawling | Johnstown | 34 | Johnstown | PA | NYC | 27-Jul | ||||||
| 1867 | July | 16 | Irvington | Irvington | 44 | Eckford | Brooklyn | 13 | Union Grounds | 9 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 27-Jul | |||
| 1867 | July | 16 | National | Washington | 86 | Buckeye | Cincinnati | 12 | Cincinnati | OH | NYC | 27-Jul | ||||||
| 1867 | July | 16 | Sherman | Brooklyn | 33 | Perserverance | 15 | Hoboken | Hudson County | NJ | NYC | 27-Jul | ||||||
| 1867 | July | 16 | Junior | Delaware | 68 | Clipper | Columbus | 28 | Columbus | OH | NYC | 27-Jul | juniors | |||||
| 1867 | July | 17 | Athletic | Philadelphia | 75 | Commonwealth | Philadelphia | 25 | Philadelphia | PA | NYC | 27-Jul | ||||||
| 1867 | July | 17 | Adriatic | New York | 18 | Franklin | Brooklyn | 67 | Union Grounds | 9 | 3.33 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 27-Jul | juniors | |
| 1867 | July | 17 | National | Washington | 82 | Louisville | Louisville | 21 | Louisville | KY | NYC | 27-Jul | ||||||
| 1867 | July | 17 | Capitol Jrs. | Madison | 55 | Capitol | Madison | 43 | Madison | WI | NYC | 3-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | July | 18 | Athletic | Philadelphia | 74 | Bristol | Philadelphia | 16 | 9 | Philadelphia | NYC | 20-Jul | ||||||
| 1867 | July | 18 | Yale University | New Haven | 36 | Harvard | Cambridge | 18 | 9 | Cambridge | MA | NYC | 27-Jul | freshmen | ||||
| 1867 | July | 18 | Yale University | New Haven | 23 | Harvard | Cambridge | 22 | 9 | 2.75 | Cambridge | MA | NYC | 27-Jul | sophs | |||
| 1867 | July | 18 | Empire | New York | 41 | Knickerbocker Base Ball | New York | 26 | Elysian Fields | Hoboken | Hudson County | NJ | NYC | 27-Jul | ||||
| 1867 | July | 18 | Quaker City | Philadelphia | 36 | Union | Camden | 14 | 9 | 2.33 | Camden | NJ | NYC | 27-Jul | ||||
| 1867 | July | 18 | Kickenepawling | Johnstown | 73 | Glade | Somerset | 16 | PA | NYC | 27-Jul | |||||||
| 1867 | July | 18 | Summit | Crestline | 96 | Enterprise | Bucyrus | 57 | Bucyrus | OH | NYC | 27-Jul | ||||||
| 1867 | July | 18 | Higginsen's Side | Atchison | 52 | Sawyer's Side | Atchison | 41 | Atchison | KS | NYC | 3-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | July | 18 | Active | Brookfield | 47 | Hesperian | St. Joseph | 44 | St. Joseph | MO | NYC | 3-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | July | 18 | Empire | St. Louis | 49 | Capital Base Ball | Jefferson City | 39 | California | MO | NYC | 10-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | July | 19 | Eckford | Brooklyn | 22 | Star | Brooklyn | 17 | 9 | 1.9 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 27-Jul | |||
| 1867 | July | 19 | Pythian | Philadelphia | 43 | Mutual | Washington | 44 | 9 | Philadelphia | PA | NYC | 27-Jul | |||||
| 1867 | July | 19 | National | Washington | 106 | Western | Indianapolis | 21 | Indianapolis | IN | NYC | 27-Jul | ||||||
| 1867 | July | 19 | Amateur | Carlisle | 71 | Excelsior | Carlisle | 21 | Carlisle | PA | NYC | 3-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | July | 19 | Athletic | East Boston | 67 | Creighton | Chelsea | 44 | Chelsea | MA | NYC | 3-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | July | 19 | Metamora | Fordham | 35 | Meteor | 24 | NY | NYC | 3-Aug | ||||||||
| 1867 | July | 19 | Winthrop | Charlestown | 42 | Mutual | Boston | 30 | Boston Common | Boston | MA | NYC | 3-Aug | |||||
| 1867 | July | 19 | Stark | Canton | 126 | Sippo | Massillon | 54 | 9 | 5.1 | Massillon | OH | NYC | 3-Aug | ||||
| 1867 | July | 19 | Excelsior | Pana | 65 | Excelsior | Pana | 24 | Pana | IL | NYC | 10-Aug | 1st v. 2nd nine | |||||
| 1867 | July | 20 | Arctic | Philadelphia | 16 | Athletic | Philadelphia | 55 | 9 | 3.4 | Philadelphia | PA | NYC | 27-Jul | ||||
| 1867 | July | 20 | Xenia | Xenia | 101 | Buckeye | Dayton | 57 | 9 | Xenia | OH | NYC | 3-Aug | |||||
| 1867 | July | 20 | Creighton | Washington | 26 | Eagle | Washington | 19 | Washington | DC | NYC | 3-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | July | 20 | Picked Nine | Carlisle | 30 | Amateur | Carlisle | 28 | Carlisle | PA | NYC | 3-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | July | 22 | National | Washington | 113 | Union | St. Louis | 26 | St. Louis | MO | NYC | 3-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | July | 22 | Keystone | Philadelphia | 45 | Union | Camden | 38 | Camden | NJ | NYC | 3-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | July | 22 | Mutual | New York | 27 | Hudson River | Newburgh | 6 | 9 | 3.66 | Newburgh | NY | NYC | 3-Aug | ||||
| 1867 | July | 22 | Maryland | Baltimore | 73 | Chesterfield | Centreville | 22 | MD | NYC | 10-Aug | |||||||
| 1867 | July | 23 | National | Washington | 53 | Empire | St. Louis | 26 | 6 | St. Louis | MO | NYC | 3-Aug | |||||
| 1867 | July | 23 | Suffolk | Huntington | 39 | Star | Hempstead | 25 | 9 | Huntington | Suffolk County | NY | NYC | 3-Aug | ||||
| 1867 | July | 23 | Olympic | New Haven | 58 | Quinnipaik | New Haven | 53 | New Haven | CT | NYC | 3-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | July | 23 | Lone Star | Mattawan | 66 | Union | Poughkeepsie | 26 | 9 | New Hamburg | NY | NYC | 3-Aug | |||||
| 1867 | July | 23 | Arctic | Philadelphia | 26 | Bachelor | Philadelphia | 17 | 9 | Philadelphia | PA | NYC | 3-Aug | |||||
| 1867 | July | 23 | Jefferson | Washington | 35 | Continental | Washington | 16 | 3.5 | Washington | DC | NYC | 3-Aug | |||||
| 1867 | July | 24 | Eureka | Boston | 45 | Boyleston | Boston | 26 | Boston Common | 9 | Boston | MA | NYC | 3-Aug | Boyleston 2nd 9 | |||
| 1867 | July | 24 | Creighton | Norfolk | 38 | Indpendent | Petersburg | 34 | Norfolk | VA | NYC | 3-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | July | 24 | Active | Buffalo | 31 | Mutual | Buffalo | 23 | Buffalo | NY | NYC | 3-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | July | 24 | Lincoln | Pittsburgh | 24 | Hiawatha | Kittanning | 19 | Pittsburgh | PA | NYC | 10-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | July | 25 | Excelsior Press | 63 | Gray and Green Co. | New York | 33 | NY | NYC | 3-Aug | ||||||||
| 1867 | July | 25 | Athletic | Philadelphia | 28 | Union | Camden | 11 | 9 | Camden | NJ | NYC | 3-Aug | |||||
| 1867 | July | 25 | Quaker City | Philadelphia | 49 | Harry Clay | Philadelphia | 40 | 6 | Philadelphia | PA | NYC | 3-Aug | |||||
| 1867 | July | 25 | National | Washington | 23 | Forest City | Rockford | 29 | Chicago | IL | NYC | 3-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | July | 25 | Enterprise | Baltimore | 115 | Association | Baltimore | 7 | Baltimore | MD | NYC | 10-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | July | 25 | Kekionga | Fort Wayne | 72 | Toledo | Toledo | 30 | Toledo | OH | NYC | 10-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | July | 26 | Mutual | New York | 45 | Harlem | Harlem | 16 | Union Grounds | 9 | 2.5 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 3-Aug | ||
| 1867 | July | 26 | Suffolk | Huntington | 20 | National | Farmingdale | 18 | 9 | 1.66 | Farmingdale | Nassau County | NY | NYC | 3-Aug | |||
| 1867 | July | 26 | Excelsior | Brooklyn | 14 | Active | New York | 9 | Capitoline Grounds | 9 | 1.9 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 3-Aug | ||
| 1867 | July | 26 | Eagle | Sparta | 50 | Amateur | Tomah | 35 | 9 | 2.33 | WI | NYC | 10-Aug | |||||
| 1867 | July | 26 | Arctic | Baltimore | 24 | Maryland | Baltimore | 22 | Baltimore | MD | NYC | 10-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | July | 26 | Clipper | Lowell | 52 | Independent | Leominster | 40 | Leominster | MA | NYC | 17-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | July | 27 | Irvington | Irvington | 24 | Star | Brooklyn | 10 | 9 | 2.25 | Irvington | Essex County | NJ | NYC | 3-Aug | |||
| 1867 | July | 27 | National | Washington | 49 | Excelsior | Chicago | 4 | Chicago | IL | NYC | 3-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | July | 27 | Live Oak | Cincinnati | 40 | Covington | Covington | 24 | Union park | Cincinnati | OH | NYC | 3-Aug | |||||
| 1867 | July | 27 | Capitol | Lansing | 37 | Sheridan | Mason | 7 | 9 | 3.1 | Lansingburgh | MI | NYC | 10-Aug | ||||
| 1867 | July | 27 | Quaker City | Philadelphia | 56 | Eagle | Norristown | 5 | 9 | 3 | Norristown | PA | NYC | 10-Aug | ||||
| 1867 | July | 27 | West | Trenton | 41 | Post | Trenton | 27 | Trenton | NJ | NYC | 10-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | July | 27 | Old Point | Fortress Monroe | 21 | Creighton | Norfolk | 5 | 5 | Norfolk | VA | NYC | 10-Aug | |||||
| 1867 | July | 27 | Hopeful | Charlestown | 36 | Red Foot | Chelsea | 15 | Chelsea | MA | NYC | 17-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | July | 27 | Flyaway | East Boston | 30 | Brookline | Brookline | 14 | 7 | Boston | MA | NYC | 17-Aug | |||||
| 1867 | July | 27 | Electric | Brighton | 21 | Everett | Brighton | 17 | Brighton | MA | NYC | 17-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | July | 27 | Winthrop | Boston | 47 | Chemung | Stoughton | 35 | Braintree | MA | NYC | 17-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | July | 27 | Mountain | Altoona | 49 | Star | Altoona | 39 | Altoona | PA | NYC | 17-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | July | 28 | Atlantic | St. Louis | 22 | Hope Jr. | St. Louis | 18 | St. Louis | MO | NYC | 10-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | July | 29 | Mutual | New York | 43 | Champion | Jersey City | 42 | Elysian Fields | 9 | 3.66 | Hoboken | Hudson County | NJ | NYC | 10-Aug | Muffins | |
| 1867 | July | 29 | Peabody | Baltimore | 39 | Excelsior | Baltimore | 22 | Baltimore | MD | NYC | 10-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | July | 29 | Ashland | New York | 21 | Young America | 21 | 10 | Hunter's Point | Queens | NY | NYC | 10-Aug | tie | ||||
| 1867 | July | 29 | National | Washington | 78 | Atlantic | Chicago | 17 | Chicago | IL | NYC | 10-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | July | 29 | Clifton | Buffalo | 94 | Active | Buffalo | 54 | Buffalo | NY | NYC | 10-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | July | 30 | Mutual | New York | 40 | Harlem | Harlem | 20 | 9 | 2.6 | Harlem | Manhattan | NY | NYC | 10-Aug | |||
| 1867 | July | 30 | Pastime | Baltimore | 36 | Maryland | Baltimore | 30 | 9 | 3 | Baltimore | MD | NYC | 10-Aug | ||||
| 1867 | July | 30 | Una | Mt. Vernon | 51 | Atlanta | Tremont | 20 | Mt. Vernon | NY | NYC | 10-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | July | 30 | Novelty | Cumberland | 68 | Advance | Cumberland | 39 | Cumberland | MD | NYC | 10-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | July | 30 | Olympic Jr. | New Haven | 83 | Quinnipiac | New Haven | 43 | New Haven | CT | NYC | 10-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | July | 31 | Atlantic | Brooklyn | 19 | Union | New York | 32 | 9 | 2.84 | Morrisania | The Bronx | NY | NYC | 10-Aug | |||
| 1867 | July | 31 | Athletic | Philadelphia | 28 | Athletic | Philadelphia | 11 | Philadelphia | PA | NYC | 17-Aug | md v single | |||||
| 1867 | July | 31 | Star | Altoona | 55 | Mountain | Altoona | 44 | Altoona | PA | NYC | 17-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | July | 31 | Crescent | Red Wing | 34 | Minneapolis | Minneapolis | 27 | Red Wing | MN | NYC | 17-Aug | juniors | |||||
| 1867 | July | Active | Philadelphia | 55 | Keystone | Philadelphia | 35 | Philadelphia | PA | NYC | 20-Jul | |||||||
| 1867 | July | Rough and Ready | Jeansville | 38 | Little Luzerne | Eckley | 36 | PA | NYC | 3-Aug | ||||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 1 | Mutual | New York | 17 | Mohawk | Brooklyn | 1 | Union Grounds | 5 | 1.66 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 10-Aug | rain | |
| 1867 | Aug. | 1 | Atlantic | Buffalo | 37 | Star | Black Rock | 25 | Buffalo | NY | NYC | 10-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 1 | Buena Vista | Brooklyn | 62 | Friendly | New York | 8 | Hoboken | Hudson County | NJ | NYC | 10-Aug | |||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 1 | Quaker City | Philadelphia | 45 | Perry | Philadelphia | 12 | 5 | Philadelphia | PA | NYC | 17-Aug | rain | ||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 1 | Jefferson | Washington | 36 | Empire | Washington | 35 | 9 | Washington | DC | NYC | 17-Aug | |||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 1 | Jerome Park | New York | 33 | Putnam | Troy | 27 | 9 | 3.5 | New York | Manhattan | NY | NYC | 17-Aug | |||
| 1867 | Aug. | 2 | Excelsior | Brooklyn | 21 | Eckford | Brooklyn | 27 | Capitoline Grounds | 9 | 2.66 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 10-Aug | ||
| 1867 | Aug. | 2 | Oriental | Brooklyn | 38 | Lone Star | Mattawan | 33 | Greenpoint | 9 | 3.16 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 10-Aug | ||
| 1867 | Aug. | 2 | Active | Buffalo | 62 | Star | Batavia | 22 | Buffalo | NY | NYC | 10-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 2 | National | Waynesboro | 37 | Kangaroo | Greencastle | 80 | Waynesboro | PA | NYC | 17-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 5 | Irvington | Irvington | 34 | Atlantic | Brooklyn | 32 | 9 | 3.25 | Irvington | Essex County | NJ | NYC | 10-Aug | |||
| 1867 | Aug. | 5 | Irvington | Irvington | 34 | Atlantic | Brooklyn | 32 | 9 | 3.3 | Irvington | Essex County | NJ | NYC | 17-Aug | |||
| 1867 | Aug. | 5 | Eon | Portland | 48 | Cushnocs | Augusta | 30 | Portland | ME | NYC | 17-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 5 | Keystone | Philadelphia | 49 | West Philadelphia | Philadelphia | 39 | 9 | Philadelphia | PA | NYC | 17-Aug | |||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 5 | Pastime | Baltimore | 53 | Pastime | Richmond | 9 | Richmond | VA | NYC | 17-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 6 | Union | Lansingburgh | 42 | Eureka | Newark | 21 | 9 | 3.84 | Lansingburgh | NY | NYC | 17-Aug | ||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 6 | Pastime | Baltimore | 70 | Athletic | Petersburg | 5 | Petersburg | VA | NYC | 17-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 6 | Advance | New Brunswick | 37 | Fleetfoot | Perth Amboy | 16 | NJ | NYC | 24-Aug | |||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 6 | Athletic | Nashville | 26 | Atlantic | Nashville | 13 | Nashville | TN | NYC | 24-Aug | Juniors | |||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 6 | Excelsior | Columbus | 74 | Empire | Columbus | 39 | Columbus | OH | NYC | 24-Aug | 2nd nines | |||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 7 | Lowell | Boston | 30 | Fraternity | Boston | 14 | Independence Square | 9 | 3 | Boston | MA | NYC | 17-Aug | |||
| 1867 | Aug. | 7 | Journalists | Chicago | 90 | Typographers | Chicago | 80 | Excelsior grounds | Chicago | IL | NYC | 17-Aug | |||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 7 | Hope | Wooster | 92 | Killbuck | Wooster | 70 | Wooster | OH | NYC | 17-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 7 | Arctic | Indianapolis | 52 | Archiell Base Ball | Indianapolis | 49 | Indianapolis | IN | NYC | 17-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 7 | Starlight | Rochester | 30 | Alert | Rochester | 12 | Rochester | NY | NYC | 17-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 7 | Antietam | Baltimore | 25 | Decatur | Baltimore | 16 | Baltimore | MD | NYC | 17-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 7 | Oneida | Baltimore | 27 | Keystone | Baltimore | 25 | Baltimore | MD | NYC | 17-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 7 | Amazon | Baltimore | 33 | Athletic | Baltimore | 30 | Baltimore | MD | NYC | 17-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 7 | Live Oak | New York | 53 | Athletic | Harlem | 9 | 6 | NY | NYC | 17-Aug | juniors | |||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 8 | Picked Nine | New York | 13 | Picked Nine | Brooklyn | 7 | Union Grounds | 9 | 1.84 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 17-Aug | Low score | |
| 1867 | Aug. | 8 | Niagara Falls | Niagara Falls | 41 | Active | Buffalo | 124 | 9 | Buffalo | NY | NYC | 17-Aug | |||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 8 | Excelsior | Baltimore | 39 | Try | Baltimore | 21 | Baltimore | MD | NYC | 17-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 8 | Erie | Baltimore | 28 | Peabody | Baltimore | 25 | Greenwood Grounds | Baltimore | MD | NYC | 17-Aug | |||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 8 | Olympic | Providence | 74 | Mechanics | Providence | 28 | Providence | RI | NYC | 17-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 8 | Jefferson | Washington | 41 | Capitol | Washington | 29 | 7 | Washington | DC | NYC | 24-Aug | |||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 8 | Aurora | Pittsburgh | 81 | Au Sable | Keeseville | 20 | Keeseville | NY | NYC | 24-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 9 | Pastime Jr. | Baltimore | 34 | St. Timothy's | Catonsville | 22 | Baltimore | MD | NYC | 17-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 9 | Holt Base Ball | Newport | 55 | Cincinnati | 46 | Newport | KY | NYC | 17-Aug | Muffins | ||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 9 | Mutual | Buffalo | 21 | Active | Buffalo | 14 | 9 | 1.6 | Buffalo | NY | NYC | 24-Aug | ||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 9 | Buckwheat | Columbus | 30 | Clipper | Westfield | 27 | Sherman | NY | NYC | 24-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 9 | Active | Buffalo | 54 | Lock City | Lockport | 41 | 7 | Lockport | NY | NYC | 24-Aug | |||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 10 | Alert | Rochester | 35 | Active | Buffalo | 24 | Rochester | NY | NYC | 24-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 10 | Niagara | Buffalo | 94 | Western Union | Buffalo | 42 | Buffalo | NY | NYC | 24-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 10 | Pawnee | East Liberty | 60 | Silver Heels | East Liberty | 26 | East Liberty | PA | NYC | 24-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 11 | Atlantic | St. Louis | 17 | Hope | St. Louis | 21 | St. Louis | MO | NYC | 24-Aug | juniors | |||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 11 | Olympic | New Haven | 42 | Oriental | Milford | 11 | CT | NYC | 24-Aug | |||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 12 | Atlantic | Brooklyn | 18 | Mutual | New York | 15 | Union Grounds | 9 | 2.5 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 17-Aug | ||
| 1867 | Aug. | 12 | Jerome Park | New York | 35 | Oriental | New York | 25 | Red House | 6 | Harlem | Manhattan | NY | NYC | 24-Aug | juniors | ||
| 1867 | Aug. | 12 | Quaker City | Philadelphia | 48 | Columbia | Bordentown | 18 | 9 | 2.16 | Bordentown | NJ | NYC | 24-Aug | ||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 12 | Boyleston | Boston | 31 | Eureka | Boston | 5 | 5 | Boston | MA | NYC | 24-Aug | |||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 12 | National | Boston | 40 | Bay State | Quincy | 27 | Quincy | MA | NYC | 24-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 12 | Mutual | Buffalo | 39 | Clifton | Buffalo | 14 | Buffalo | NY | NYC | 24-Aug | Clifton 2nd nine | |||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 12 | Regalia | Troy | 59 | Golden Tip | Sturgeon City | 16 | Sturgeon City | NY | NYC | 24-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 12 | Unknown | Rutland | 57 | Middlebury College | Middlebury | 46 | Rutland | VT | NYC | 24-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 13 | Niblo's Theatre | New York | 36 | New York Theatre | New York | 12 | Hoboken | Hudson County | NJ | NYC | 24-Aug | |||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 13 | Unknown | 32 | Greenhorn | New York | 4 | Hoboken | Hudson County | NJ | NYC | 31-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 13 | Meteor | 37 | Eldridge | New York | 13 | NY | NYC | 31-Aug | ||||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 13 | Green Mountain | Brooklyn | 25 | Jefferson | 22 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 31-Aug | juniors | |||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 14 | Mutual | New York | 8 | Union | Morrisania | 9 | Union Grounds | 10 | 2.1 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 24-Aug | Low score | |
| 1867 | Aug. | 14 | Americus | Newark | 32 | Gotham | New York | 24 | 9 | 2.5 | NJ | NYC | 24-Aug | |||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 14 | Athletic | Philadelphia | 58 | Star | Allentown | 4 | 9 | Philadelphia | PA | NYC | 24-Aug | |||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 14 | Resolute | New Brighton | 63 | Energetic | Bridgewater | 27 | Rochester | NY | NYC | 24-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 14 | Union | Lansingburgh | 17 | Eagle | Florence | 9 | Northampton | MA | NYC | 24-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 14 | Eureka | Newark | 35 | Charter Oak | Hartford | 9 | 9 | 2.33 | Newark | Essex County | NJ | NYC | 31-Aug | |||
| 1867 | Aug. | 14 | Commercial | Detroit | 52 | Oakland | Holley | 42 | Detroit | MI | NYC | 31-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 14 | Alert | Detroit | 27 | Diamond | Fenton | 21 | Detroit | MI | NYC | 31-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 14 | Monitor | St. John's | 61 | National | Parma | 32 | Detroit | MI | NYC | 31-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 14 | Lorimer | Brooklyn | 18 | Conselyea | Brooklyn | 14 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 31-Aug | juniors | ||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 14 | Empire | 86 | Dantive | 39 | NY | NYC | 31-Aug | |||||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 14 | Chelsea | 26 | National | 24 | NY | NYC | 31-Aug | Chelsea 2nd nine | ||||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 14 | Americus | Newark | 38 | Ottawa | 33 | NY | NYC | 31-Aug | ||||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 15 | Ristori | Tarentum | 36 | Lincoln | Pittsburgh | 24 | Tarentum | PA | NYC | 24-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 15 | Union | Lansingburgh | 8 | Hampden | Springfield | 6 | 5 | 1.5 | Springfield | MA | NYC | 24-Aug | ||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 15 | Union | Wayne | 41 | Creighton | Detroit | 27 | Detroit | MI | NYC | 31-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 15 | Ann Arbor | Ann Arbor | 50 | Tecumseh | Tecomseh | 11 | Detroit | MI | NYC | 31-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 15 | Custer | Ionia | 62 | Omega | Flint | 50 | Detroit | MI | NYC | 31-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 15 | Pacific | 52 | Benson | 40 | NY | NYC | 31-Aug | |||||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 16 | Exercise | New York | 11 | New York World | New York | 9 | East New York | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 24-Aug | |||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 16 | Independent | Petersburg | 20 | Creighton | Norfolk | 17 | Petersburg | VA | NYC | 24-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 16 | Victoria | Ingersoll | 19 | Ann Arbor Jr. | Ann Arbor | 29 | Detroit | MI | NYC | 31-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 16 | Maple Leaf | Hamilton | 19 | Welkin | Port Huron | 10 | Detroit | MI | NYC | 31-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 16 | Allegheny | Allegheny | 50 | Young Canadians | Woodstock | 35 | Detroit | MI | NYC | 31-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 16 | Ashland | Lexington | 94 | Woodford | Versailles | 26 | Versailles | KY | NYC | 31-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 16 | Clinton | Yorkville | 16 | Star | Yorkville | 3 | NY | NYC | 31-Aug | |||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 17 | Eon | Portland | 24 | Athletic | Portland | 18 | Portland | ME | NYC | 24-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 17 | Athletic | Philadelphia | 29 | Camden | Camden | 3 | 9 | Philadelphia | PA | NYC | 31-Aug | |||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 17 | Woolen Mills | Lawrenceburg | 108 | Aurora | Aurora | 53 | 8 | IN | NYC | 31-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 17 | Central City | syracuse | 44 | Auburn | Auburn | 26 | NY | NYC | 31-Aug | |||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 17 | Independent Base Ball | Brooklyn | 45 | Resolute | Brooklyn | 17 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 31-Aug | |||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 17 | Excelsior | Weymouth | 31 | Mechanics | East Weymouth | 28 | Weymouth | MA | NYC | 31-Aug | 2nd nines | |||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 17 | Occidental | Brookfield | 47 | Active | Brookfield | 24 | Brookfield | MO | NYC | 31-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 19 | Athletic | Philadelphia | 23 | Union | Morrisania | 10 | Union Grounds | 9 | 2.5 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 24-Aug | ||
| 1867 | Aug. | 19 | Alert | Rochester | 26 | Mutual | Albany | 44 | Parade Ground | 9 | Albany | NY | NYC | 31-Aug | juniors | |||
| 1867 | Aug. | 19 | Quaker City | Philadelphia | 30 | Columbia | Bordentown | 12 | 9 | 1.84 | Philadelphia | PA | NYC | 31-Aug | ||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 19 | Ann Arbor | Ann Arbor | 45 | Battle Creek | Battle Creek | 37 | Detroit | MI | NYC | 31-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 19 | Montauk | North New York | 51 | Pathfinders | West Parma | 28 | Morrisania | The Bronx | NY | NYC | 31-Aug | |||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 19 | Mountain | Ebensburg | 53 | Muffin Nine | Cresson | 28 | Ebensburg | PA | NYC | 31-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 19 | Clifton | Buffalo | 31 | Niagara Falls | Niagara Falls | 19 | Buffalo | NY | NYC | 31-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 19 | Keystone | Philadelphia | 36 | West Philadelphia | Philadelphia | 16 | Philadelphia | PA | NYC | 7-Sep | ||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 20 | Athletic | Philadelphia | 18 | Mutual | New York | 16 | 9 | 3.5 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 31-Aug | |||
| 1867 | Aug. | 20 | Pastime | Baltimore | 15 | Maryland | Baltimore | 47 | 9 | Baltimore | MD | NYC | 31-Aug | |||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 20 | Allegheny | Allegheny | 31 | Detroit | Detroit | 16 | Detroit | MI | NYC | 31-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 20 | Ashland | 16 | Young America | 19 | Hunter's Point | Queens | NY | NYC | 31-Aug | |||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 20 | Independent Base Ball | Brooklyn | 22 | Mohawk | Brooklyn | 13 | Capitoline Grounds | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 31-Aug | ||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 20 | Active | Brookfield | 53 | Pastime | Chillicothe | 24 | Brookfield | MO | NYC | 21-Sep | ||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 21 | Eckford | Brooklyn | 19 | Athletic | Philadelphia | 23 | Union Grounds | 9 | 2.16 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 31-Aug | ||
| 1867 | Aug. | 21 | Oriental | Brooklyn | 32 | Eclectic | Brooklyn | 22 | Red House | Harlem | Manhattan | NY | NYC | 31-Aug | ||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 21 | Sherman | Brooklyn | 41 | Lightfoot | 22 | NY | NYC | 31-Aug | ||||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 22 | Eagle | New York | 8 | Excelsior | Brooklyn | 35 | Capitoline Grounds | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 31-Aug | ||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 23 | Mutual | New York | 34 | Eureka | Newark | 21 | Union Grounds | 9 | 3.33 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 31-Aug | ||
| 1867 | Aug. | 23 | Live Oak | Cincinnati | 35 | Reliable | Covington | 45 | Covington | KY | NYC | 31-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 23 | Keystone | Philadelphia | 52 | Ralston | Philadelphia | 22 | Camden | NJ | NYC | 7-Sep | ||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 23 | Atlantic | Pittsburgh | 29 | Lincoln | Pittsburgh | 22 | Union park | Pittsburgh | PA | NYC | 7-Sep | |||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 23 | Crescent | New London | 29 | Independent | Salem | 21 | OH | NYC | 14-Sep | |||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 24 | Bradstreet Press | New York | 36 | Sanford, Harroun & Co. | New York | 18 | Hoboken | Hudson County | NJ | NYC | 31-Aug | |||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 24 | Quaker City | Philadelphia | 36 | Harry Clay | Philadelphia | 17 | 9 | 2.6 | Philadelphia | PA | NYC | 7-Sep | ||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 24 | Active | Mt. Savage | 19 | Novelty | Cumberland | 21 | 10 | Mt. Savage | MD | NYC | 7-Sep | |||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 24 | Hudson | New York | 44 | Hope | New York | 33 | Hoboken | Hudson County | NJ | NYC | 7-Sep | |||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 24 | Juniata | Hollidaysburg | 51 | Bald Eagle | Tyrone | 15 | Tyrone | PA | NYC | 7-Sep | ||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 26 | Atlantic | Brooklyn | 11 | Picked Nine | 24 | Union Grounds | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 31-Aug | |||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 26 | Athletic | Philadelphia | 84 | Hamilton | Philadelphia | 9 | Philadelphia | PA | NYC | 7-Sep | ||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 26 | Mutual | New York | 40 | National | Washington | 16 | 9 | 3.5 | Washington | DC | NYC | 7-Sep | ||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 26 | Union | Morrisania | 22 | Active | Newark | 12 | 9 | 2.1 | Newark | Essex County | NJ | NYC | 7-Sep | |||
| 1867 | Aug. | 26 | Lowell | Boston | 83 | Independent | Leominster | 19 | Boston Common | Boston | MA | NYC | 7-Sep | |||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 26 | Flyaway | Boston | 51 | Fraternity | Boston | 34 | Boston | MA | NYC | 7-Sep | ||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 26 | Mountaineers | Ebensburg | 41 | Star | Altoona | 31 | Ebensburg | PA | NYC | 7-Sep | ||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 27 | Mutual | New York | 47 | Pastime | Baltimore | 31 | 9 | 3.5 | Baltimore | MD | NYC | 7-Sep | ||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 27 | Union | Morrisania | 25 | Eckford | Brooklyn | 22 | Eckford grounds | 9 | 2.5 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 7-Sep | ||
| 1867 | Aug. | 27 | Quaker City | Philadelphia | 36 | Union | Camden | 15 | Philadelphia | PA | NYC | 7-Sep | ||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 27 | Howes & Macy | New York | 27 | Henry Clawes & Co. | New York | 21 | Enterprise grounds | 7 | Staten Island | NY | NYC | 7-Sep | ||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 27 | Active | New York | 37 | Fulton | New York | 11 | Satellite grounds | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 7-Sep | ||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 27 | Sherman | Brooklyn | 36 | Picked Nine | 15 | Hoboken | Hudson County | NJ | NYC | 7-Sep | ||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 27 | Alert | Cumberland | 44 | Advance | Cumberland | 33 | Cumberland | MD | NYC | 14-Sep | ||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 28 | Mutual | New York | 23 | Athletic | Philadelphia | 21 | 9 | 3.66 | Philadelphia | PA | NYC | 7-Sep | ||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 28 | National | Camp Schofield | 46 | Pastime | Lynchburg | 11 | Lynchburg | VA | NYC | 14-Sep | ||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 28 | Patapsco | Westminster | 27 | Maryland | Baltimore | 46 | Westminster | MD | NYC | 14-Sep | ||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 29 | Washington Market | 26 | Fulton Market | New York | 13 | Morrisania | The Bronx | NY | NYC | 7-Sep | juniors | |||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 30 | Mutual | New York | 20 | Keystone | Philadelphia | 28 | 9 | 4 | Camden | NJ | NYC | 7-Sep | ||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 30 | Pequot | New London | 25 | Oceanic | Mystic | 18 | CT | NYC | 7-Sep | |||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 30 | Actors | Washington | 40 | Actors | Washington | 31 | Washington | DC | NYC | 14-Sep | ||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 31 | Mutual | New York | 28 | West Philadelphia | Philadelphia | 23 | West Philadelphia Grds | 7 | 3.6 | Philadelphia | PA | NYC | 7-Sep | |||
| 1867 | Aug. | 31 | Active | Cumberland | 50 | Novelty | Cumberland | 36 | Cumberland | MD | NYC | 14-Sep | ||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 31 | Eon | Portland | 22 | Cushnocs | Augusta | 21 | Augusta | ME | NYC | 14-Sep | ||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | 31 | Tri-Mountain | Boston | 55 | Eureka | East Cambridge | 30 | Riverside Park | Boston | MA | NYC | 14-Sep | |||||
| 1867 | Aug. | Sheridan | Cohoes | 71 | Independent | Waterford | 38 | Cohoes | NY | NYC | 24-Aug | |||||||
| 1867 | Aug. | Independent Base Ball | Brooklyn | 29 | Washington | 21 | Greenpoint | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 31-Aug | ||||||
| 1867 | Sep. | 2 | Empire | New York | 19 | Atlantic | Brooklyn | 32 | Union Grounds | 9 | 2 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 7-Sep | ||
| 1867 | Sep. | 2 | Occidental | Denver | 58 | Unknown | Denver | 20 | Denver | CO | NYC | 28-Sep | ||||||
| 1867 | Sep. | 3 | Union | Lansingburgh | 28 | National | Washington | 31 | 10 | 3.1 | Washington | DC | NYC | 14-Sep | ||||
| 1867 | Sep. | 3 | Picked Nine | New York | 22 | Picked Nine | Brooklyn | 17 | Union Grounds | 2.16 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 14-Sep | |||
| 1867 | Sep. | 3 | Peabody | Baltimore | 19 | Eureka Jr. | Baltimore | 19 | Baltimore | MD | NYC | 14-Sep | tie | |||||
| 1867 | Sep. | 4 | Lowell | Boston | 20 | Tri-Mountain | Boston | 18 | 9 | Boston | MA | NYC | 14-Sep | |||||
| 1867 | Sep. | 4 | Mutual | New York | 19 | Irvington | Irvington | 16 | Union Grounds | 9 | 2.84 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 14-Sep | ||
| 1867 | Sep. | 4 | Vermyle & Co. | New York | 11 | Jay Cooke & Co. | New York | 15 | Satellite grounds | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 14-Sep | ||||
| 1867 | Sep. | 5 | Athletic | Philadelphia | 47 | Union | Lansingburgh | 8 | 9 | 2.75 | Philadelphia | PA | NYC | 14-Sep | ||||
| 1867 | Sep. | 5 | Atlantic | Brooklyn | 21 | Eureka | Newark | 19 | 9 | 2.1 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 14-Sep | |||
| 1867 | Sep. | 7 | Union | Lansingburgh | 20 | Quaker City | Philadelphia | 10 | 9 | 2.33 | Philadelphia | PA | NYC | 14-Sep | ||||
| 1867 | Sep. | 10 | Union | Morrisania | 33 | Eureka | Newark | 14 | Union Grounds | 8 | 2.33 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 21-Sep | dark | |
| 1867 | Sep. | 10 | Eckford | Brooklyn | 30 | Keystone | Philadelphia | 14 | Keystone grounds | Philadelphia | PA | NYC | 21-Sep | 2nd nines | ||||
| 1867 | Sep. | 10 | Eckford | Brooklyn | 29 | Keystone | Philadelphia | 6 | 9 | Philadelphia | PA | NYC | 21-Sep | |||||
| 1867 | Sep. | 10 | Mohawk | Brooklyn | 28 | Starlight | Brooklyn | 8 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 21-Sep | |||||
| 1867 | Sep. | 10 | Quickstep | Paducah | 43 | Eclipse | Cairo | 16 | Cairo | IL | NYC | 28-Sep | ||||||
| 1867 | Sep. | 11 | Atlantic | Brooklyn | 36 | Excelsior | Rochester | 13 | Union Grounds | 9 | 2.33 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 21-Sep | ||
| 1867 | Sep. | 11 | Union | Morrisania | 29 | Excelsior | Rochester | 21 | Union Grounds | 9 | 2.6 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 21-Sep | ||
| 1867 | Sep. | 11 | Eckford | Brooklyn | 31 | West Philadelphia | Philadelphia | 45 | 8 | Philadelphia | PA | NYC | 21-Sep | |||||
| 1867 | Sep. | 11 | Eckford | Brooklyn | 53 | West Philadelphia | Philadelphia | 31 | Philadelphia | PA | NYC | 21-Sep | 2nd nines | |||||
| 1867 | Sep. | 11 | Knickerbocker | Albany | 49 | Hampden | Springfield | 39 | Springfield | MA | NYC | 21-Sep | ||||||
| 1867 | Sep. | 12 | Active | Indianapolis | 38 | Franklin | Indianapolis | 31 | Indianapolis | IN | NYC | 21-Sep | ||||||
| 1867 | Sep. | 12 | Athletic | Philadelphia | 77 | Enterprise | Baltimore | 12 | 7 | Philadelphia | PA | NYC | 21-Sep | |||||
| 1867 | Sep. | 12 | Camden | Camden | 42 | Union | Camden | 29 | Camden | NJ | NYC | 21-Sep | ||||||
| 1867 | Sep. | 12 | Peabody | Baltimore | 38 | Eureka Jr. | Baltimore | 17 | Baltimore | MD | NYC | 28-Sep | ||||||
| 1867 | Sep. | 12 | Mountaineers | Ebensburg | 35 | Iron | Johnstown | 31 | Ebensburg | PA | NYC | 28-Sep | ||||||
| 1867 | Sep. | 13 | Excelsior | Brooklyn | 16 | Eckford | Brooklyn | 12 | Union Grounds | 9 | 2 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 21-Sep | ||
| 1867 | Sep. | 13 | Pastime | Baltimore | 18 | Quaker City | Philadelphia | 15 | 9 | 2.16 | Philadelphia | PA | NYC | 21-Sep | ||||
| 1867 | Sep. | 13 | Athletic | Philadelphia | 17 | Mutual | New York | 18 | Union Grounds | 9 | 3 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 28-Sep | ||
| 1867 | Sep. | 13 | Monitor | Waterbury | 22 | Pequot | New London | 20 | 9 | New London | CT | NYC | 28-Sep | |||||
| 1867 | Sep. | 13 | Huron | New York | 47 | Erie | New York | 33 | 9 | New York | Manhattan | NY | NYC | 28-Sep | ||||
| 1867 | Sep. | 14 | Union | Camden | 27 | Athletic | Philadelphia | 57 | 9 | 3 | Philadelphia | PA | NYC | 21-Sep | ||||
| 1867 | Sep. | 14 | Excelsior | Rochester | 17 | Star | Brooklyn | 37 | Capitoline Grounds | 6 | 2.25 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 21-Sep | ||
| 1867 | Sep. | 14 | Pastime | Baltimore | 9 | Keystone | Philadelphia | 39 | 9 | 2.25 | Philadelphia | PA | NYC | 21-Sep | ||||
| 1867 | Sep. | 14 | Quaker City | Philadelphia | 22 | Camden | Camden | 21 | 6 | Camden | NJ | NYC | 21-Sep | dark | ||||
| 1867 | Sep. | 14 | Bradley | Fort Harker | 60 | Smoky Hill | Ellsworth City | 22 | 9 | 3 | Fort Harker | KS | NYC | 28-Sep | ||||
| 1867 | Sep. | 14 | Independent | Titusville | 100 | Odds and Ends | Titusville | 31 | Titusville | PA | NYC | 28-Sep | ||||||
| 1867 | Sep. | 16 | Atlantic | Brooklyn | 28 | Athletic | Philadelphia | 16 | Union Grounds | 9 | 2.25 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 21-Sep | ||
| 1867 | Sep. | 16 | Eckford | Brooklyn | 40 | Athletic | Philadelphia | 39 | Satellite grounds | 9 | 3.3 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 21-Sep | 2nd nines | |
| 1867 | Sep. | 16 | Creighton | Norfolk | 48 | Independent | Petersburg | 9 | 9 | Suffolk | VA | NYC | 28-Sep | |||||
| 1867 | Sep. | 17 | Mutual | New York | 32 | West Philadelphia | Philadelphia | 18 | Union Grounds | 9 | 2.75 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 28-Sep | ||
| 1867 | Sep. | 17 | Quaker City | Philadelphia | 63 | Perry | Philadelphia | 3 | 9 | Philadelphia | PA | NYC | 28-Sep | |||||
| 1867 | Sep. | 17 | Lone Star | Syracuse | 39 | Sherman | Utica | 22 | Syracuse | NY | NYC | 28-Sep | ||||||
| 1867 | Sep. | 18 | National | Boston | 26 | Mystic | Somerville | 31 | Somerville | MA | NYC | 21-Sep | ||||||
| 1867 | Sep. | 18 | Irvington | Irvington | 55 | Pastime | Baltimore | 17 | Baltimore | MD | NYC | 28-Sep | ||||||
| 1867 | Sep. | 18 | National | Washington | 111 | Pastime | Baltimore | 9 | Baltimore | MD | NYC | 28-Sep | ||||||
| 1867 | Sep. | 18 | New York County Clerks | New York | 63 | New York Registers | New York | 28 | Empire Grounds | 8 | 2.75 | Hoboken | Essex County | nj | NYC | 28-Sep | ||
| 1867 | Sep. | 18 | Columbus | Columbus | 61 | Empire | Columbus | 39 | Columbus | GA | NYC | 5-Oct | Empire 2nd nine | |||||
| 1867 | Sep. | 19 | Atlantic | Brooklyn | 34 | West Philadelphia | Philadelphia | 11 | Union Grounds | 7 | 1.75 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 28-Sep | ||
| 1867 | Sep. | 19 | Irvington | Irvington | 22 | National | Washington | 33 | Washington | DC | NYC | 28-Sep | ||||||
| 1867 | Sep. | 19 | Union | Morrisania | 19 | Oriental | Brooklyn | 42 | Satellite grounds | 8 | 3 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 28-Sep | ||
| 1867 | Sep. | 19 | Lone Star | Pittston | 15 | Rival | Scranton | 30 | 9 | PA | NYC | 5-Oct | ||||||
| 1867 | Sep. | 19 | Monitor | Westport | 35 | Union | Westport | 36 | 10 | Westport | NY | NYC | 5-Oct | or CT | ||||
| 1867 | Sep. | 19 | Delphian | Delphi | 34 | Hoosier | Lafayette | 35 | 9 | Delphi | IN | NYC | 5-Oct | |||||
| 1867 | Sep. | 20 | Quaker City | Philadelphia | 27 | Irvington | Irvington | 14 | Quaker City grounds | 9 | 2.34 | Philadelphia | PA | NYC | 28-Sep | |||
| 1867 | Sep. | 20 | Quaker City | Philadelphia | 27 | Irvington | Irvington | 14 | Philadelphia | PA | NYC | 28-Sep | ||||||
| 1867 | Sep. | 20 | National | Washington | 36 | Maryland | Baltimore | 18 | Baltimore | MD | NYC | 28-Sep | ||||||
| 1867 | Sep. | 20 | Excelsior | Brooklyn | 26 | Eckford | Brooklyn | 15 | Union Grounds | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 28-Sep | ||||
| 1867 | Sep. | 20 | Mohawk | New York | 28 | Independent Base Ball | Brooklyn | 23 | Greenpoint | 7 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 28-Sep | |||
| 1867 | Sep. | 20 | Griswold | Lansingburgh | 54 | Star | Lansingburgh | 15 | The Green | 5 | Lansingburgh | NY | NYC | 5-Oct | ||||
| 1867 | Sep. | 21 | Athletic | Philadelphia | 36 | Union | Morrisania | 32 | 8 | 3.5 | Philadelphia | PA | NYC | 28-Sep | ||||
| 1867 | Sep. | 21 | Rising Star | Leominster | 105 | Sheridan | North Lancaster | 11 | Leominster | MA | NYC | 5-Oct | ||||||
| 1867 | Sep. | 23 | Mutual | New York | 29 | Union | Morrisania | 24 | Union Grounds | 9 | 2.5 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 28-Sep | ||
| 1867 | Sep. | 23 | Atlantic | Brooklyn | 8 | Athletic | Philadelphia | 28 | 9 | 2.33 | Philadelphia | PA | NYC | 28-Sep | ||||
| 1867 | Sep. | 23 | World | 47 | Champion | 21 | NY | NYC | 5-Oct | |||||||||
| 1867 | Sep. | 23 | Irvington | Irvington | 39 | Eckford | Brooklyn | 33 | Irvington | Essex County | NJ | NYC | 5-Oct | |||||
| 1867 | Sep. | 23 | Tri-Mountain | Boston | 46 | Lowell | Boston | 35 | Boston Common | Boston | MA | NYC | 5-Oct | |||||
| 1867 | Sep. | 23 | Waban | Newton | 3 | Fraternity | Boston | 8 | Riverside Park | Boston | MA | NYC | 5-Oct | |||||
| 1867 | Sep. | 23 | Eagle | Florence | 38 | Rolleston | Fitchburg | 33 | Riverside Park | Boston | MA | NYC | 5-Oct | |||||
| 1867 | Sep. | 23 | Excelsior | Brooklyn | 41 | Eureka | Newark | 23 | Capitoline Grounds | 7 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 5-Oct | |||
| 1867 | Sep. | 23 | Rising Star | Leominster | 48 | Resolute | Clinton | 36 | Clinton | MA | NYC | 5-Oct | ||||||
| 1867 | Sep. | 24 | Quaker City | Philadelphia | 21 | Atlantic | Brooklyn | 24 | 9 | Philadelphia | PA | NYC | 5-Oct | |||||
| 1867 | Sep. | 24 | Jefferson | Washington | 14 | Athletic | Philadelphia | 50 | 9 | 3.16 | Philadelphia | Brooklyn | PA | NYC | 5-Oct | |||
| 1867 | Sep. | 24 | Union | Morrisania | 21 | Union | Lansingburgh | 26 | Union Grounds | 9 | 3 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 5-Oct | ||
| 1867 | Sep. | 24 | Eagle | Florence | 63 | Fraternity | Boston | 15 | Riverside Park | Boston | MA | NYC | 5-Oct | |||||
| 1867 | Sep. | 24 | Phoenix | Nashville | 25 | Nashville | Nashville | 20 | Nashville | TN | NYC | 12-Oct | ||||||
| 1867 | Sep. | 25 | Keystone | Philadelphia | 12 | Atlantic | Brooklyn | 12 | 9 | 1.75 | Philadelphia | PA | NYC | 5-Oct | rain, tie | |||
| 1867 | Sep. | 25 | Mutual | New York | 19 | Union | Lansingburgh | 6 | Union Grounds | 5 | 1.25 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 5-Oct | rain | |
| 1867 | Sep. | 25 | Tri-Mountain | Boston | 51 | Fraternity | Boston | 26 | Riverside Park | Boston | MA | NYC | 5-Oct | |||||
| 1867 | Sep. | 26 | Atlantic | Brooklyn | 36 | West Philadelphia | Philadelphia | 31 | 9 | Philadelphia | PA | NYC | 5-Oct | |||||
| 1867 | Sep. | 26 | Cincinnati | Cincinnati | 28 | Hickory | McConnellsville | 16 | 2.66 | Cincinnati | OH | NYC | 5-Oct | |||||
| 1867 | Sep. | 26 | Irvington | Irvington | 47 | Union | Lansingburgh | 8 | 9 | 2.3 | Irvington | Essex County | NJ | NYC | 5-Oct | |||
| 1867 | Sep. | 26 | Rolleston | Fitchburg | 73 | Fraternity | Boston | 25 | Riverside Park | 5 | Boston | MA | NYC | 5-Oct | ||||
| 1867 | Sep. | 26 | Tri-Mountain | Boston | 16 | Eagle | Florence | 6 | Riverside Park | 5 | Boston | MA | NYC | 5-Oct | Eagles quit | |||
| 1867 | Sep. | 27 | Mutual | New York | 29 | Eckford | Brooklyn | 20 | Union Grounds | 9 | 2.33 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 5-Oct | ||
| 1867 | Sep. | 27 | Hudson River | Newburgh | 29 | Union | Lansingburgh | 23 | Newburgh | NY | NYC | 5-Oct | ||||||
| 1867 | Sep. | 27 | Pequot | New London | 40 | Riverside | Norwich | 8 | New London | CT | NYC | 5-Oct | ||||||
| 1867 | Sep. | 27 | Eagle | Sparta | 27 | Union | Sparta | 25 | Sparta | WI | NYC | 12-Oct | ||||||
| 1867 | Sep. | 28 | Active | New York | 11 | Union | Morrisania | 15 | Satellite grounds | 10 | 2.45 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 5-Oct | ||
| 1867 | Sep. | 28 | Western Union Tele | Brooklyn | 28 | Demas Barnes | Brooklyn | 18 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 5-Oct | |||||
| 1867 | Sep. | 28 | Tri-Mountain | Boston | 42 | Lowell | Boston | 22 | Riverside Park | 9 | Boston | MA | NYC | 12-Oct | ||||
| 1867 | Sep. | 28 | Picked Nine | Philadelphia | 39 | Picked Nine | Philadelphia | 31 | 9 | Philadelphia | PA | NYC | 19-Oct | |||||
| 1867 | Sep. | 29 | Eagle | Memphis | 42 | Confederate | Memphis | 34 | Memphis | TN | NYC | 12-Oct | ||||||
| 1867 | Sep. | 30 | Galvin's Side | 34 | Zettlein's Side | 11 | Union Grounds | 5 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 5-Oct | Exhibition | ||||
| 1867 | Sep. | 30 | Live Oak | Albany | 54 | Athletic | Harlem | 9 | New York | Manhattan | NY | NYC | 12-Oct | |||||
| 1867 | Sep. | 30 | Gate City | Keokuk | 46 | Athletic | Keokuk | 48 | Keokuk | IA | NYC | 12-Oct | ||||||
| 1867 | Sep. | Drinkwater & Whiting | New York | 47 | Trade | New York | 38 | NY | NYC | 28-Sep | ||||||||
| 1867 | Sep. | Trade Nine | Boston | 35 | Whiting & Drinkwater Co. | Boston | 33 | Boston | MA | NYC | 5-Oct | |||||||
| 1867 | Sep. | Belfast | Belfast | 53 | Lime Rock | Rockland | 53 | 7 | Belfast | ME | NYC | 12-Oct | tie, rain | |||||
| 1867 | Oct. | 1 | Live Oak | Albany | 31 | Amity | Brooklyn | 24 | Capitoline Grounds | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 12-Oct | ||||
| 1867 | Oct. | 1 | Armenia | 48 | Armenia | 39 | NY | NYC | 12-Oct | Single v. Md | ||||||||
| 1867 | Oct. | 1 | Arctic | Philadelphia | 16 | Quaker City | Philadelphia | 26 | 8 | 2.75 | Philadelphia | PA | NYC | 19-Oct | ||||
| 1867 | Oct. | 2 | Mutual | New York | 18 | Eureka | Newark | 21 | Union Grounds | 9 | 2.66 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 12-Oct | ||
| 1867 | Oct. | 2 | Live Oak | Albany | 37 | Picked Nine | New York | 28 | Red House | New York | Manhattan | NY | NYC | 12-Oct | ||||
| 1867 | Oct. | 2 | Keystone | Philadelphia | 20 | Excelsior | Brooklyn | 15 | Capitoline Grounds | 9 | 2.6 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 12-Oct | ||
| 1867 | Oct. | 3 | Olympic Theatre | New York | 41 | Fifth Avenue Theatre | New York | 16 | Mt. Morris | 9 | 2.84 | Harlem | Manhattan | NY | NYC | 12-Oct | ||
| 1867 | Oct. | 3 | Lone Star | Syracuse | 34 | Mutual | Albany | 29 | Syracuse | NY | NYC | 12-Oct | ||||||
| 1867 | Oct. | 3 | Keystone | Philadelphia | 21 | Atlantic | Brooklyn | 18 | Union Grounds | 9 | 2.2 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 12-Oct | ||
| 1867 | Oct. | 3 | Excelsior | Philadelphia | 42 | Unique | Brooklyn | 37 | Satellite grounds | 7 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 19-Oct | AA clubs | ||
| 1867 | Oct. | 3 | Olympic | Washington | 11 | Quaker City | Philadelphia | 29 | Quaker City grounds | 9 | 2.84 | Philadelphia | PA | NYC | 19-Oct | |||
| 1867 | Oct. | 4 | Keystone | Philadelphia | 31 | Eckford | Brooklyn | 13 | Union Grounds | 6 | 2.2 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 12-Oct | rain | |
| 1867 | Oct. | 7 | Mutual | New York | 17 | Atlantic | Brooklyn | 32 | Union Grounds | 9 | 2.5 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 12-Oct | ||
| 1867 | Oct. | 7 | Harvard | Cambridge | 18 | Excelsior | Brooklyn | 6 | 9 | Boston | MA | NYC | 19-Oct | |||||
| 1867 | Oct. | 8 | Pequot | New London | 33 | Bridgeport | Bridgeport | 32 | 7 | Bridgeport | CT | NYC | 19-Oct | |||||
| 1867 | Oct. | 8 | Alert | Norwalk | 29 | Liberty | Norwalk | 22 | 8 | Norwalk | CT | NYC | 19-Oct | |||||
| 1867 | Oct. | 10 | Atlantic | Brooklyn | 13 | Union | Morrisania | 14 | Union Grounds | 9 | 2.1 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 19-Oct | ||
| 1867 | Oct. | 10 | Olympic Theatre | New York | 38 | Fifth Avenue Theatre | New York | 24 | Red House | New York | Manhattan | NY | NYC | 19-Oct | ||||
| 1867 | Oct. | 11 | Niagara | Buffalo | 13 | Excelsior | Rochester | 18 | Rochester | NY | NYC | 19-Oct | ||||||
| 1867 | Oct. | 12 | Athletic | Philadelphia | 57 | Quaker City | Philadelphia | 8 | Philadelphia | PA | NYC | 19-Oct | ||||||
| 1867 | Oct. | 12 | St. Timothy | Catonsville | 18 | Peabody | Baltimore | 24 | 9 | 2.45 | Baltimore | MD | NYC | 26-Oct | juniors | |||
| 1867 | Oct. | 14 | Atlantic | Brooklyn | 36 | Irvington | Irvington | 12 | Union Grounds | 9 | 2.33 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 26-Oct | ||
| 1867 | Oct. | 16 | Armenia | 62 | Armenia | 35 | 7 | NJ | NYC | 26-Oct | Single v. md | |||||||
| 1867 | Oct. | 17 | Niagara | Troy | 23 | Troy | Troy | 21 | Troy | NY | NYC | 26-Oct | ||||||
| 1867 | Oct. | 18 | Union | Lansingburgh | 21 | Atlantic | Brooklyn | 41 | 9 | 2.16 | Troy | NY | NYC | 26-Oct | ||||
| 1867 | Oct. | 18 | Monitor | Waterbury | 18 | Pequot | New London | 16 | Waterbury | CT | NYC | 2-Nov | ||||||
| 1867 | Oct. | 19 | Central City | syracuse | 34 | Knickerbocker | Albany | 16 | Syracuse | NY | NYC | 2-Nov | ||||||
| 1867 | Oct. | 19 | Penneseewasses | Norway | 29 | Bowdoin | Brunswick | 8 | Brunswick | ME | NYC | 2-Nov | ||||||
| 1867 | Oct. | 21 | National | Washington | 15 | Union | Lansingburgh | 16 | 9 | 2.25 | Lansingburgh | NY | NYC | 2-Nov | ||||
| 1867 | Oct. | 22 | Clipper | Buffalo | 39 | Niagara | Buffalo | 23 | Buffalo | NY | NYC | 2-Nov | ||||||
| 1867 | Oct. | 23 | National | Washington | 29 | Mutual | New York | 37 | Union Grounds | 8 | 2.75 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 2-Nov | dark | |
| 1867 | Oct. | 24 | Seneca | Oil City | 22 | Enterprise | Pittsburgh | 20 | Pittsburgh | PA | NYC | 2-Nov | ||||||
| 1867 | Oct. | 24 | Quaker City | Philadelphia | 35 | Eagle | Norristown | 17 | 9 | 2.1 | Philadelphia | PA | NYC | 2-Nov | ||||
| 1867 | Oct. | 25 | Cincinnati | Cincinnati | 44 | Active | Indianapolis | 25 | 9 | 2.9 | Cincinnati | OH | NYC | 2-Nov | ||||
| 1867 | Oct. | 25 | Allegheny | Allegheny | 35 | Seneca | Oil City | 22 | Allegheny | PA | NYC | 2-Nov | ||||||
| 1867 | Oct. | 25 | Hudson | New York | 31 | Alida | Ravenswood | 24 | Mt. Morris | 7 | New York | Manhattan | NY | NYC | 2-Nov | |||
| 1867 | Oct. | 26 | National | Washington | 11 | Excelsior | Brooklyn | 26 | Capitoline Grounds | 9 | 2.33 | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 2-Nov | ||
| 1867 | Oct. | 26 | White Haven | White Haven | 22 | Picked Nine | 22 | 4 | White Haven | PA | NYC | 9-Nov | tie | |||||
| 1867 | Oct. | 27 | National | Washington | 23 | Irvington | Irvington | 29 | 9 | 2.84 | Irvington | Essex County | NJ | NYC | 2-Nov | |||
| 1867 | Oct. | 28 | Mutual | New York | 52 | Jefferson | New York | 9 | Union Grounds | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 9-Nov | ||||
| 1867 | Oct. | 30 | Pride of the South | Memphis | 44 | Bluff City | Memphis | 39 | Memphis | TN | NYC | 16-Nov | ||||||
| 1867 | Oct. | 31 | Eldridge | New York | 23 | Rising Sun | 22 | Hoboken | Hudson County | NJ | NYC | 9-Nov | ||||||
| 1867 | Oct. | Sheridan | Boston | 31 | Star | Boston | 22 | Boston Common | Boston | MA | NYC | 26-Oct | juniors | |||||
| 1867 | Oct. | Atlantic | Cincinnati | 38 | Highlander | Cincinnati | 13 | 7 | Cincinnati | OH | NYC | 2-Nov | ||||||
| 1867 | Nov. | 2 | Athletic | Philadelphia | 37 | West Philadelphia | Philadelphia | 10 | 2.45 | Philadelphia | PA | NYC | 9-Nov | |||||
| 1867 | Nov. | 1 | Social | 16 | Sparta | Newark | 15 | Jersey City | Hudson County | NJ | NYC | 9-Nov | ||||||
| 1867 | Nov. | 2 | Irvington | Irvington | 22 | Eureka | Newark | 9 | Newark | Essex County | NJ | NYC | 9-Nov | |||||
| 1867 | Nov. | 6 | Picked Nine | New Jersey | 23 | Picked Nine | New York | 24 | NJ State Fair Grounds | 9 | 2.5 | Waverly | NJ | NYC | 16-Nov | |||
| 1867 | Nov. | 7 | Keystone | Philadelphia | 21 | Quaker City | Philadelphia | 13 | Keystone grounds | 7 | 2.16 | Camden | NJ | NYC | 16-Nov | |||
| 1867 | Nov. | 9 | Athletic | Philadelphia | 16 | Quaker City | Philadelphia | 10 | 6 | 2.5 | Philadelphia | PA | NYC | 16-Nov | ||||
| 1867 | Nov. | 8 | Olympic Theatre | New York | 40 | Old Bowery Theatre | New York | 15 | Union Grounds | Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | NYC | 16-Nov | ||||
| 1867 | Nov. | 8 | Gramercy | New York | 21 | Oriental | New York | 5 | Red House | 7 | 1.9 | New York | Manhattan | NY | NYC | 16-Nov | ||
| 1867 | Nov. | 4 | Hope and Anchor | Pawtucket | 70 | Zephyr | Prividence | 29 | Camp Burnside | Pawtucket | RI | NYC | 16-Nov | |||||
| 1867 | Nov. | 5 | Eagle | Trenton | 43 | Neptune | Trenton | 31 | Trenton | NJ | NYC | 16-Nov | ||||||
| 1867 | Nov. | 13 | Athletic | Philadelphia | 38 | National | Washington | 12 | 6 | 2.9 | Washington | DC | NYC | 23-Nov | ||||
| 1867 | Nov. | 14 | Athletic | Philadelphia | 17 | Olympic | Washington | 9 | 9 | 2 | Washington | DC | NYC | 23-Nov | ||||
| 1867 | Nov. | 16 | Wide Awake | Carrollton | 22 | Lone Star | Carrollton | 21 | 9 | Carrollton | OH | NYC | 30-Nov | |||||
| 1867 | Nov. | 16 | Athletic | Philadelphia | 55 | Bristol | Bristol | 14 | 2.75 | Bristol | PA | NYC | 30-Nov | |||||
| 1867 | Nov. | 28 | Quaker City | Philadelphia | 65 | Wawasset | Wilmington | 9 | 7 | 2.84 | Wilmington | DE | NYC | 7-Dec | ||||
| 1867 | Nov. | 15 | Live Oak | Fort Bridger | 43 | Lightfoot | Dakota Territory | 19 | Fort Bridger | WY | NYC | 7-Dec | ||||||
| 1867 | Nov. | 28 | Union | Washington | 77 | Pastime | Baltimore | 37 | Washington | DC | NYC | 7-Dec | ||||||
| 1867 | Nov. | 28 | Deaf and Dumb Asylum | Washington | 20 | Union | Washington | 19 | Washington | DC | NYC | 7-Dec | ||||||
| 1867 | Nov. | 18 | Quaker City | Philadelphia | 66 | Keystone | Philadelphia | 6 | Philadelphia | PA | NYC | 7-Dec | quit | |||||
| 1867 | Nov. | 28 | Maryland | Baltimore | 34 | Olympic | Washington | 14 | 6 | Baltimore | MD | NYC | 7-Dec | |||||
| 1867 | Santa Fe | Santa Fe | 24 | Santa Fe | Santa Fe | 16 | Santa Fe | NM | NYC | 13-Jul | ||||||||
| 1867 | Enterprise | Andover | 24 | Phillips Academy | Andover | 9 | Andover | MA | NYC | 12-Oct | ||||||||